Hepper is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more.

8 Best Cat Toys for Older Cats in 2021 – Top Picks & Buyers Guide

Catit Design Senses Circuit Cat Toy_Chewy

Older cats don’t move and jump like they did when they were young. As your pets begin to age, you have to adapt to their new bodies and provide them with toys that work better for their age. Switching out inappropriate toys for new ones ensures that your cat stays in the best health without the risk of hurting themselves. It’s not always simple to know exactly which toys to select, especially if this is your first time dealing with older pets. With so many products, you soon create a list that becomes too large to choose from. With feline health as our top priority, our reviews of cat products for older cats are created to help you make a smart and beneficial choice that makes you and your cat happy.

A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites

Rating Image Product Details
Best Overall
Winner
Catit Design Senses Circuit Toy Catit Design Senses Circuit Toy
  • Safe for multiple cats    
  • Comes with two balls    
  • Expandable
  • Best Value
    Second place
    PetSafe Bolt Interactive Laser Cat Toy PetSafe Bolt Interactive Laser Cat Toy
  • Hands-free play    
  • 15-minute activity intervals    
  • Mental and physical stimulation
  • Premium Choice
    Third place
    SmartyKat Hot Pursuit Concealed Motion Cat Toy SmartyKat Hot Pursuit Concealed Motion Cat Toy
  • Different speed settings    
  • Various toy attachments    
  • Affordable
  • Frisco Cat Tracks Butterfly Toy Frisco Cat Tracks Butterfly Toy
  • Sturdy    
  • Cheap    
  • Encourages different interactions
  • SmartyKat Feather Whirl Motion Cat Toy SmartyKat Feather Whirl Motion Cat Toy
  • Affordable    
  • Multi-cat toy    
  • Gentle exercise
  • The 10 Best Cat Toys for Older Cats – Reviews & Top Picks 2021

    1. Catit Design Senses Circuit Toy – Best Overall

    Catit Design Senses Circuit Cat Toy

    Dimensions: 1.5 x 4 x 13 inches
    Weight: 1.6 ounces
    Material: Polyester

    We’ve found that the best overall cat toys for older cats include the Catit design senses circuit toy. Aside from the affordable price, this toy keeps your older cat’s hunting skills in shape without requiring them to jump and run as if they were still young. They can lay and bat at the swirl-patterned ball or be a bit more active if they’re feeling up for it.

    This toy features a motion-activated ball that catches the eye of almost all cats. The pieces snap together easily, and the top sections are removable to make it easier for you catch to catch the ball. Unfortunately, the battery from the ball isn’t replaceable, but you can buy additional ones separately.

    Pros
    •    Affordable
    •    Easy assembly
    •    Safe for multiple cats
    •    Comes with two balls
    •    Expandable

    Cons

    • Can’t replace ball batteries


    2.   PetSafe Bolt Interactive Laser Cat Toy – Best Value

    PetSafe Bolt Interactive Layer Toy

    Dimensions: 3 x 3 x 9 inches
    Weight: 7.84 ounces
    Material: Plastic

    One of the best cat toys for older cats for the money is the PetSafe interactive laser toy. This is a battery-operated toy that is affordable and keeps your cats busy for 15 minutes at a time. You can change the motion range on the moving laser to keep your older cats from running too much, making it an easy way to entertained bored cats.

    You don’t have to be supervising while this cat toy works its magic. However, you can use it manually if you prefer. It encourages mental stimulation and exercise, but some cats are known to be bothered by laser toys in general.

    Pros
    •    Affordable
    •    Hands-free play
    •    15-minute activity intervals
    •    Mental and physical stimulation

    Cons

    •  Could irritate some cats


    3. SmartyKat Hot Pursuit Concealed Motion Cat Toy – Premium Choice

    SmartyKat Hot Pursuit cat toy_Chewy

    Dimensions: 22.51 x 22.51 x 2.99 inches
    Weight: 8.8 ounces
    Material: Plastic

    This electronic toy has different speed settings that allow you to control how active your cat should be. A wand moves below a plastic tarp to get your cats intrigued and hone their hunting skills. With different wand attachments to choose from, you can even customize it to make your cat more interested.

    This toy is most suitable for individual play, but it small enough that a senior cat will enjoy not having to run much. It is very affordable, but the tarp does tend to rip easily if your feline has some sharp claws that they’re using.

    Pros
    •    Different speed settings
    •    Various toy attachments
    •    Affordable

    Cons

    • Best for solo play only


    4. Frisco Cat Tracks Butterfly Toy

    Frisco Cat Tracks Butterfly Cat Toy

    Dimensions: 9.84 x 3.43 x 9.84 inches
    Weight: N/A
    Material: Plastic

    This stationary offers a few different ways for your older cat to play. With a butterfly floating on a wire from the top and three levels of movable balls, your senior kitty can lay and paw at this toy for as long as they want. This toy is cheap enough for nearly all price ranges and sturdy enough where it won’t tip over.

    The one thing you have to keep an eye on with this toy is the wire that attaches to the butterfly. If play gets too rough, it could come off and pose a choking hazard for cats with chewing problems.

    Pros
    •    Sturdy
    •    Cheap
    •    Encourages different interactions

    Cons

    • Wire is a choking hazard if removed


    5. SmartyKat Feather Whirl Motion Cat Toy

    SmartyKat Feather Whirl

    Dimensions: 2.75 x 2.75 x 10.62 inches
    Weight: 4.48 ounces
    Material: Plastic

    Cats with exceptional hunting skills might get a kick out of this unique toy. The battery-operated base rolls in erratic motions that make the attached feather dart back and forth as if it were imitating a real bird. It keeps your older cat stalking appropriate items instead of your legs and turns one with one push of a button. The motor is fairly quiet but could bother some people.

    Because it isn’t overly powerful, this toy doesn’t roll too far or fast that it tires your cat out. If they get a hold of the feathers a few too many times, you might have to buy a replacement.

    Pros
    •    Affordable
    •    Multi-cat toy
    •    Gentle exercise

    Cons

    •    Feather gets destroyed
    •    Motor makes noise


    6. PetFusion Ambush Interactive Cat Toy

    PetFusion Ambush Interactive Electronic Cat Toy

    Dimensions: 6.8 x 6.8 x 2.8 inches
    Weight: 1.3 pounds
    Material: Plastic

    This interactive toy has a LED lights and a colorful attachment that immediately intrigues your cats to play. It is able to be used at night or during the day and comes with a replacement feather in case the first gets ruined. It is best to use on smooth surfaces like hardwood floors instead of carpet.

    Your cats get 8 minutes of playtime before it automatically shuts off to extend the battery life, which is included when you first buy it. It is a little pricier than some of the other listed cat toys. However, it doesn’t require your senior cats to move too far to get some entertainment.

    Pros
    •    Batteries included
    •    Nighttime play

    Cons

    •    Pricey
    •    Not ideal for carpet


    7. Frisco Sushi Plush Catnip Cat Toy

    Frisco Sushi Plush Cat Toy with Catnip

    Dimensions: 3.5 x 2.5 x 1.5 inches
    Weight: .16 ounces
    Material: Polyester

    Cats can’t get enough of toys filled with catnip. These cute toys come in a four-pack that looks like different sushi rolls and a wasabi packet. These toys are all different sizes and allow your cat to claw, bite, and relax while they play. The soft material is gentle on their teeth and paws as well.

    Although affordable and full of catnip, you can not add more to the inside. With most plush toys, it’s possible that the seems could rip after lots of play. You should not use these toys more than a few times a week or they could become immune to the catnip effects.

    Pros
    •    Cheap
    •    Four-pack

    Cons

    • Catnip isn’t refillable
    • Seems could rip
    • Only use a few times per week

     


    8. Smart Cat Peek and Play Toy

    SmartCat Peek & Play Toy Box

    Dimensions: 10 x 10 x 3 inches
    Weight: N/A
    Material: Polyester

    Have you noticed that your cats of all ages love to hide their toys in small crevices? This instinct doesn’t go away as your cat ages. This puzzle toy comes with two foam balls that allow your kitty to drop them, hide them, and paw at them all day. Unfortunately, it doesn’t come with replacement balls and isn’t a toy that is going to fit in everyone’s budget. However, we enjoy that our cats can still act like young kittens without having to move like them.

    Pros
    •    Puzzle stimulates brain
    •    Comes with two balls

    Cons

    •    Pricey
    •    Replacements sold separately
    •    Not safe for all cats


    Buyer’s Guide

    If you own a cat, whether a kitten or senior, you likely have a large selection of toys for your fur kids to choose from. From electronic toys to simple balls, bonding with our cats during playtime is a great way to establish a connection and keep them healthy both mentally and physically. This isn’t as easy as our cat’s age. Their preference for toys could change based on how their bodies feel and how easy they are to use.

    Is Your Cat a Senior?

    Older cats are only considered seniors when they are 10 years old. Some older cats still love running, jumping, and playing like they did when they were kittens, but it is still a nice idea to start adapting their toys to fit their bodies.

    Cats start to sleep more as they age and don’t play as often as they used to. This means that they also don’t get enough exercise and might lead them to be obese. When you pick out toys for older cats, you want something that encourages them to move their bodies without spending so much energy that it hurts them or disinterests them. Finding age-appropriate toys isn’t always easy, but it is possible.

    Age-Appropriate Cat Toy Characteristics

    Many of us have our cats for years and already know what kinds of toys they are interested in. Do your best to base your new choice on what they already play with. If you don’t know, ask yourself a few different questions. Do they enjoy catnip? Are they more likely to play with noisy toys or silent ones? Do they hunt, stalk, or chase more often? Do laser toys bother or excite them? Once you understand their preferences, it is a lot easier to make a decision when it comes time to buy.

    Conclusion

    Age-appropriate cat toys are crucial as your pets make the transition from a young buck to an old feline. Our reviews have found that the best overall cat toy for older cats is the Catit Design Senses Circuit Toy, while the best for your money is the PetSafe Bolt Interactive Laser Cat Toy. Even if you don’t go with either of these, there are plenty of options on this list that encourage your senior cat to take fewer naps and get the exercise necessary to keep them living a healthy life.

      Your Cart
      Your cart is empty
      Go to shop
        Calculate Shipping