10 Best Dog Treats at PetSmart in 2024: Reviews & Top Picks

Our dogs are our best friends, so of course, they deserve treats now and then. Choosing the right treat for our favorite furry friend can be a struggle, though; we need to find a treat they enjoy while also ensuring it isn’t too unhealthy. Plus, we have to find treats suitable for our dog’s size. It’s a lot to consider!

If you’ve been having difficulties finding a great treat for your pup, never fear because we’re here to help. And if you’re a PetSmart¹ fan, then you’re in luck. Here you’ll find quick reviews and pros and cons of the ten best dog treats at PetSmart. It’ll only take a few minutes to get through, so keep reading to get the lowdown on these delicious dog snacks!

A Quick Glance at Our Favorites of 2024

The 10 Best Dog Treats at PetSmart

1. Milk-Bone Soft & Chewy Dog Treat All Ages – Filet Mignon – Best Overall

Milk-Bone dog treats are a classic for a reason! Having been around since 1908¹, this company has the making of dog treats down to a science. That’s why these soft and chewy snacks are our choice for the best overall dog treat at PetSmart.

Made with real beef (and chicken), these tasty snacks have a beef and filet mignon flavor your pet will gobble up. Plus, you can feel good feeding them to your dog, knowing they’ve been fortified with 12 essential minerals and vitamins. And with a soft texture, these dog treats are suitable for dogs of all ages and sizes. Bonus—they’re easy to break into smaller bits to stuff inside a puzzle toy, so your pup has a blast while staying occupied.

Some dogs and dog parents found the smell of these off-putting, though. There were also some pet owners that weren’t thrilled about the ingredient list containing Red 40, Yellow 5, and Blue 2 at the very end, as they found those ingredients unhealthy.

---

2. Hill’s Science Diet Soft Savories Dog Treat – Natural, Peanut Butter & Banana – Best Value

Budgets can be tight sometimes, so it’s good to know which dog treats are an excellent value but also one your pup will be a fan of. If you’re shopping at PetSmart, we recommend these treats from Hill’s Science Diet as the best dog treats for the money.

With real peanut butter plus yummy banana flavor, these soft, chewy treats should be a big hit with adult pups of all sizes. They have no artificial flavors or preservatives for you to worry about, and a few dog owners stated these were wonderful for those pups with sensitive stomachs. However, there are peas in this treat—peas and legumes have been loosely linked¹ to dog heart disease, so you’ll need to decide how large a concern that is for your pet.

Several people also stated that these treats weren’t as soft as advertised and were rather hard.

---

3. Merrick Power Bites Adult Dog Treats – Rabbit, Corn Free, Gluten Free – Premium Choice

Looking for a more premium dog treat? Then you’ll want to try out these Merrick Power Bites! With an alternate protein source in the form of a rabbit, these treats should be excellent for pups with food allergies or sensitivities. And because these treats are made with real rabbits, they offer plenty of protein to keep muscles strong and healthy. They’re also gluten and grain-free if that’s a concern; however, being grain-free means there are peas, which have been linked to heart disease. Overall, these snacks seem to be quite popular with dogs, though.

There were some rare complaints of dogs getting diarrhea after these, and a few people disliked how they smelled.

---

4. Blue Buffalo Puppy Treats – Best for Puppies

When you have a puppy, you want a treat suitable for them, and these treats from Blue Buffalo hit the mark. Not only are these made with real chicken, but they’re packed with omega fatty acids that aid in healthy brain development. You’ll also find whole grains for fiber, along with veggies and fruits here, which means these treats contain essential minerals and vitamins your pup needs to keep growing as it should. Pet owners say these treats are excellent to use during training, as most dogs love them.

However, extremely picky eaters weren’t big fans of these. There were also a couple of complaints about these snacks drying out quickly after the bag had been opened.

---

5. Purina Beggin’ Strips for Dogs

Beggin’ Strips are another extremely popular dog treat and for good reason! Made from real pork and with a delicious bacon taste, these treats are soft and chewy enough for any pup to enjoy. They’re also easy to tear into tiny pieces for little dogs or for training purposes. Plus, you’ll find no artificial colors or flavors here, so you can feel good about giving them to your four-legged pal.

There were a few recent complaints about treats purchased being dry and burnt, and a couple of dogs threw up after eating these.

---

6. Simply Nourish Source Freeze-Dried Dog Treat

Whether your dog has allergies or you just want to feed it a treat that’s a bit healthier, these Simply Nourish freeze-dried treats fit the bill. With a single ingredient—real chicken—these tasty snacks are high in protein but low in calories and fat. Plus, a single ingredient means these are also grain-free if your dog requires a grain-free diet (with the bonus of no peas)! According to pet owners, dogs (and cats) went absolutely wild over these treats.

The only complaints about these were one person stating their treats expired before the expiration date and a single person finding a small bone in a piece of chicken.

---

7. Old Mother Hubbard P-Nuttier Large Biscuit Dog Treats

If you’ve been searching for an all-natural treat for your favorite pup, then look no further. Old Mother Hubbard’s P-Nuttier biscuits contain only all-natural ingredients, such as whole wheat flour, peanut butter, carrots, and apples. And since they’re larger, these treats are excellent for large breed dogs (though these biscuits are easily broken into pieces for small dogs, too).

There were a handful of dogs whose stomachs didn’t agree with these treats, but other than that, the only rare complaint was that the treats were a bit hard.

---

8. Dentley’s Gourmet Rawhide Stuffed Rolls – Sweet Potato & Chicken Dog Treats

These fun treats are fabulous for small and medium breeds that are moderate chewers. Longer-lasting than most treats, Dentley’s Rawhide contains real chicken and sweet potato for a unique flavor and helps clean teeth while your pup chews. These chews are also incredibly high in protein (but also a bit higher in calories than others on this list).

A couple of dogs did have stomach issues after consuming these—one dog became constipated, while the other experienced vomiting and diarrhea.

---

9. SmartBones SmartSticks Dog Treat

Though these SmartBones SmartSticks Dog Treats contain real chicken and vegetables, they’re a little less healthy than others on this list (and have peas listed further down in the ingredients). However, these chews are easily digestible and claim to be long-lasting, so they should keep your favorite dog busy while it chows down. And these snacks have been fortified with minerals and vitamins your pup needs.

Several people stated these treats weren’t as long-lasting as advertised, though. A few people also said these were too hard for their dogs to eat.

---

10. Greenies Adult Regular Dog Dental Treats

Finally, we have another dog-approved and much loved treat—Greenies! Dogs love the chewy texture and yummy taste of Greenies, while pet parents love the fact these snacks help keep teeth clean and freshen breath. Plus, Greenies states their treats are made with highly digestible ingredients to help your pup avoid any digestive issues after eating.

A few dog parents said their pets with stomachs had digestive issues after eating these, though, so if your pup’s stomach is sensitive, these might not be the best. Other than that, picky eaters didn’t seem to enjoy eating Greenies.

Buyer’s Guide — Choosing the Best Dog Treats at PetSmart

So, how do you go about deciding which treat is the absolute best one for your favorite furry friend? Choosing a suitable dog treat involves considering a few factors.

Ingredients

What ingredients are used to make a dog treat is by far the most important thing you should look at. You want to ensure that healthy ingredients are used in your pet’s snacks, rather than fillers or chemicals that will make them ill. Real meat should, ideally, be the first ingredient in any dog treat you choose, and the rest of the ingredient list should consist of items that are easily recognizable, such as fruits, vegetables, minerals, and vitamins.

You may want to go with a dog treat that has fewer ingredients, as the less ingredients there are, the less likely your pup will be allergic or sensitive to something. Also, decide how concerned you are about peas and legumes and their tentative link to heart disease in our four-legged friends; if that’s a concern, check ingredient lists carefully, as sometimes you’ll find these further down the list.

Treat Size

The size of a dog treat is important, as well, as differently sized dogs will require treats of differing sizes. For example, exceptionally small treats could be a choking hazard for large dogs, while toy breeds wouldn’t do well with a huge treat. Some larger treats can be broken into tinier pieces, but not all can so choose your treat size carefully.

How Healthy They Are

Other than looking at whether a dog treat contains healthy ingredients, you should also look at the overall healthiness. Does a dog treat have a high amount of fat or calories? Then, it’s probably best to avoid feeding it to your pet. Particularly if your dog is overweight, you’ll need to look closely at dog treats’ fat and caloric content.

Texture

Dogs are individuals, which means they’ll prefer some textures over others, so ensure any treat you purchase is in a texture your pet likes. You might also want to figure out whether a certain texture is simpler to break into smaller pieces if needed or whether a different texture might have your pup chewing away on its treat for several minutes. And if you’re searching for treats to use during training, go with ones that can be easily eaten, so you don’t need to pause a lesson to let your dog eat its reward!

Reviews

Still not sure if a particular treat is the right one for your pet? Then head to the review section and read what other pet parents have to say. This is one of the fastest ways to determine if a dog treat is suitable for your furry pal.

Cost

Cost is always a consideration, no matter what you’re buying. Dog treats come at all different prices, so be sure to look at several different kinds to find the one most suited for your budget.

Conclusion

When you want the best overall dog treat at PetSmart, you’ll want to consider Milk-Bone Soft & Chewy Dog Treat, as they’re made with real beef and suitable for dogs of all sizes and ages. If you want to get the best dog treat for the money, try Hill’s Science Diet Soft Savories Dog Treat since they’re a reasonable price and seem good for dogs with sensitive stomachs. Finally, if you want something a touch more premium, our recommendation is Merrick Power Bites Adult Dog Treats since they offer an alternative protein to the ones dogs are commonly allergic to, making them excellent for pups with food allergies and sensitivities.

---

Featured Image Credit: James Lacy, Unsplash