6 Best Halloween Dog Toys – 2025 Reviews & Top Picks

Yes, it’s nearly here. The heat of summer is slowly dwindling and fall is in the air. When this time of year rolls around, you and your dog must welcome it in style. That’s why choosing the perfect Halloween dog toy for this year’s spooky season is a must. No pet owner who loves cool nights, horror movies, and things that go bump in the night wants their dog playing with boring toys when things can be much more exciting. Let’s take a look at 6 toys we feel are your best bets at helping your dog celebrate Halloween in style. Once you pick the perfect one, then you can start debating on what costumes you and your pup will be sporting for Trick or Treat.

A Quick Look at Our Favorites in 2025

Rating	Image	Product	Details
Best Overall		Frisco Haunted Shack Puzzle Dog Toy	Interactive to keep a dog’s mind occupied Cute design Safe for your dog’s teeth and mouth	Check Price
Best Value		Frisco Halloween Fetch Squeaky Balls	Glow in the dark for easy finding during play Comes with 4 balls included Won’t damage a dog’s teeth or gums	Check Price
Premium Choice		Disney Halloween Hocus Pocus Cauldron	Encourages problem-solving Offers hours of play Includes 5 plushies for your pet	Check Price
Best for Puppies		Frisco My First Halloween Reversible Plush Toy	Cute designs for the holiday Plush design is safe for puppies Has 3 squeakers inside for maximum noise	Check Price
		Frisco Halloween Boo Plush with Rope	Cute Halloween design Features plushies, squeakers, & rope in one toy	Check Price

The 6 Best Halloween Dog Toys

1. Frisco Haunted Shack Hide-and-Seek Puzzle Dog Toy – Best Overall

Our choice for the best overall Halloween dog toy of this year is the Frisco Haunted Shack Hide-and-Seek Puzzle dog toy. This interactive dog toy is a great way to keep your dog’s mind sharp while allowing them to have fun throughout the Halloween season. The haunted shack serves as the base. You’ll also find a black cat, a ghost, and a skeleton squeaky toy that you can hide inside the shack. This allows your dog to search out the toys and have fun doing so. What we love is the interactive puzzle this toy offers. We also like the soft material it’s made from which is safe for your dog’s teeth and mouth.

The only true downside we found with the Haunted Shack toy is that it is best suited for small and medium dogs as heavy chewers can tear the toy easily. Heavy chewers or dogs who are rough on toys wouldn’t have the opportunity to enjoy this toy as it should be.

2. Frisco Halloween Glow in the Dark Fetch Squeaky Balls – Best Value

Our pick for the best Halloween dog toy of this year for the money is the Frisco Halloween Glow in the Dark Squeaky Balls. Like our best overall pick, our best value also comes from Frisco which is a respected company when it comes to pet toys. These fetch balls offer hours of fun for your dog, but once the darkness comes, they can really have some fun. This pack of 4 balls comes in multiple Halloween designs. The safe, non-abrasive material allows you and your pet to play at night without the worry of losing their favorite toy. We also love that these squeaky balls won’t damage or hurt your dog’s teeth and gums.

Unfortunately, if you have a smaller breed of dog, they may have issues picking up these balls. They aren’t exactly sized to fit small mouths. As with many dog toys, you’ll also find that heavy chewers may destroy these balls quickly.

3. Disney Halloween Hocus Pocus Cauldron Hide and Seek Puzzle Squeaky Plush – Premium Choice

The Disney Hocus Pocus puzzle cauldron is a fun way for your dog to stay interested in a toy. Included in the set are a spooky Halloween cauldron and 5 squeaky plushies of the Sanderson sisters and their sidekicks from the movie Hocus Pocus. Each plushie can be played with on its own, but when you want to encourage your dog’s problem-solving skills, simply place the plushies inside the cauldron and let your dog figure out ways to get them out.

This toy is good for smaller breeds but isn’t sized for bigger dog breeds. You may also find that the cauldron isn’t overly sturdy and may be torn up easily if your dog is a heavy chewer.

4. Frisco My First Halloween Reversible Plush Toy – Best for Puppies

They aren’t puppies forever! This “My First Halloween” Plushie from Frisco is the perfect way to allow your pup the chance to celebrate this fun holiday without worries. Your pup can use this toy as a cuddle buddy, a squeaky, or a chew toy. It is soft and safe for whatever they decide to do with it. You’ll also love that the other side says, “Too Cute to Spook,” making it perfect for puppies around the world. What we really like is the 3 squeakers inside that ensure any pup can get their toy to work.

Like with any toy you purchase for your pet, this one isn’t indestructible. If your puppy tries and chews hard enough, it can get the squeakers out. Keep this in mind when allowing them to play unsupervised.

5. Frisco Halloween Boo Plush with Rope Squeaky Toy

This Halloween toy brings everything your dog may love into one toy. It features a tug rope with 3 Halloween plushies. What they’ll really enjoy is the fact each plushie also squeaks. Your pet will spend hours playing on its own. When you’re ready to play as well, tug rope is the perfect game, especially for bigger dogs. Be sure not to pull too hard so as not to damage your dog’s teeth. The rope is also good for fetch games as it gives you a little extra when you toss it.

If your dog is a master of rope toys, make sure they only play while supervised. Dogs have been known to unravel the rope and chew on the strings or leave them all over the house.

6. Frisco Halloween Rubber Pumpkin Treat Dispenser Toy

This little toy by Frisco is a great way to keep your dog occupied and rewarded for its curiosity. This treat toy is made of rubber which makes it great for heavy chewers. You can even toss it for your pet and watch them chase it when it bounces. Simply fill this pumpkin with your dog’s favorite treats or food. They will get to interact as they figure out how to get their reward out of the pumpkin while they play. The best part, this toy is dishwasher safe after your pup gets its reward.

The only issue we found with this Halloween dog toy is the hole to retrieve the treats. It’s quite large. This means you can’t use smaller-sized treats for your pet. If you have a smaller dog breed that can’t eat large treats this toy may not be the right choice for them.

Buyer’s Guide: Finding the Best Halloween Dog Toys

Buying your dog a Halloween toy should be a fun experience for both of you. This is especially true if you’re a lover of the spooky season as well. The 6 gifts we’ve reviewed above all bring a little something different to the (Ouija) board and can make for fun times for the entire family. Let’s take a look at the criteria we used when choosing these gifts so you know what to look for when shopping.

Theme

The first thing to keep in mind is that these toys are for Halloween. This is the perfect time of the year to let your creativity and your humor fly. Jack-o-lanterns, ghosts, witches, and pumpkins are all the rage. Perhaps you even have a preferred ghoul you want to share with your dog. Either way, if you want the perfect dog toy for the Halloween season, avoid elves, reindeer, and Easter bunnies. Unless they’re zombies or ghouls, of course.

Materials

Another thing we kept in mind was the materials each toy was made out of. The last thing you want to do is offer your dog a toy, Halloween-themed or otherwise, that can hurt them. One of the most common injuries when it comes to toys is damage to the teeth and gums. We searched for toys that were soft enough that they shouldn’t hurt your dog, no matter their size. Unfortunately, being soft also means that heavy chewers may damage the toys quickly, so always keep that information in mind.

Enjoyment

Yes, this is possibly the most important thing to remember when choosing your dog a gift, whether it’s Halloween-themed or not. Plushies, squeaky toys, interactive toys, and ropes are favorites among dogs. If your pup simply loves a plush, this list has just what you need. The same can be said for the other toy types. Just remember that whatever toy you choose, your dog will love it even more if you and the family are a part of the fun and game this spooky season.

Our Halloween Dog Toys Selection Process

Our Hepper team includes experienced writers and editors who collaborate closely with licensed veterinarians to find the best, most beneficial pet products. Customer reviews, brand reputation, veterinary insights, and, occasionally, hands-on testing are a few factors they consider when making their selections. Our goal is to choose and review only the highest-quality products to help our readers make informed decisions that benefit both them and their pets.

Why Trust Hepper?

Hepper has been an evolving online resource since 2007, specializing in innovating and retailing a range of cat furniture, gear, and toys, and pet consumables. This experience has given our team valuable insights into selecting Halloween dog toys. Our passionate team of animal-loving writers, editors, and veterinarians is truly committed to helping readers make the best choices for their pet companions. We are focused on delivering accurate information and recommending the highest-quality products available. Our team is wholeheartedly invested in the health and well-being of pets everywhere, believing that expert knowledge is key to success.

In Conclusion

If you’re ready to put the scare into your dog’s Halloween, these toys in this review are right up your alley. Our top pick, the Frisco Haunted Shack Hide and Seek toy is great for dogs who love stimulation with a bit of a spooky squeak involved. For the pooch that loves fetch, the Frisco Glow in the Dark Squeaky Balls is the perfect toy. It’s both affordable and fun for both you and your dog. No matter which toy you choose from this spooky collection, the season will be “boo”tiful for you and your pet.

Featured Image Credit: Olha Yefimova, Shutterstock