10 Best Indestructible Dog Toys in 2024 – Reviews & Top Picks 

Do you have a dog that can tear up a new toy in 30 seconds? It can be frustrating to buy more toys and waste money, and the best thing for heavy chewers is an indestructible dog toy.

There are so many brands on the market that it can be hard to know which one to buy. To help, we’ve compiled a list of reviews of the best indestructible dog toys. We’ve also included a buyer’s guide so you know which features to look out for. Read on for our recommendations.

A Quick Glance at the Winners (Updated in 2024)

The 10 Best Indestructible Dog Toys

1. GUCHO Freezabke Dog Chew Toys — Best Overall

The GUCHO Freezable Dog Chew Toy is our pick for the best overall toy because it’s made of a rigid polymer-nylon material that can hold up to even the most aggressive chewer. It’s BPA and phthalate-free, so you don’t have to worry about an increased risk of cancer. 

The thick rim around the toy can stand up to tough chewing, and it has ridges and knobs to support healthy teeth and gums. It’s also durable and weatherproof and washes clean. It comes in two sizes, so you can choose the best one for your dog.

For some dogs, the material might be too hard.

---

2. Nylabone Dura Chew Dog Toy — Best Value

The Nylabone Dura Chew Dog Toy is one of the best indestructible dog toys for the money. It comes in various flavors, so you (or your pup) can choose the one you like best. It’s available in four chewing styles: Puppy, Moderate, Strong, and Power. This allows you to choose the most appropriate size and strength for your dog.

The Power chew is for large dogs who are also aggressive chewers. It’s made of durable nylon, so it can withstand enthusiastic chewing. In addition to the chewing styles, it comes in seven sizes, from Puppy to Large. For some dogs, the material may be too hard to the point where it damages their teeth.

A dog who aggressively chews the toy may also create sharp protrusions that can hurt the soft tissues of their mouth.

---

3. Monster K9 Dog Chew Toys — Premium Choice

The Monster K9 Dog Chew Toy is made from tough, industrial-strength natural rubber. The material is completely safe and non-toxic. It comes with a lifetime replacement guarantee, so if your dog somehow manages to destroy it, the company will replace it.

Because of its doughnut shape, it can be played with in many ways. It can be used as a chew toy for playing fetch or tug-of-war. The toy is aggressive-chewer-approved, which means that some of the toughest breeds have been unable to destroy it.

The rubber on the Monster K9 toy flakes off over time, particularly if it’s been exposed to water. Because of the rubber, there’s a strong smell right out of the package. Strong, determined chewers will probably be able to tear holes in this toy.

---

4. Benebone Wishbone Durable Dog Chew Toy

The Benebone Wishbone Durable Dog Chew comes in four sizes and has an unmistakable bacon odor that dogs love but some owners dislike. Its unique wishbone shape is easy for dogs to grab with their mouths and provides hours of chewing fun. 

Benebone’s products are made in the USA, and their line of Wishbones is suitable for dogs weighing 15 to 120 pounds. Most customers were happy with the chew toys and thought they lasted longer than similar brands. However, some thought the smallest size was still too big for their little pups.

---

5. Doggie Dooley Indestructible Best Ball

The Doggie Dooley Virtually Indestructible Best Ball is great for dogs who love pushing and herding. It’s a durable, hard plastic ball, so it doesn’t puncture easily like a tennis ball. It floats in water, which makes it a great toy for water-loving dogs. Its size makes it fun for large dogs over 60 lbs.

The material that this ball is made out of can be too hard for some dogs. It can wear down their teeth over time. It also has questionable durability since it can be punctured by strong chewers.

---

6. Pet Qwerks Dinosaur BarkBone

The Pet Qwerks Dinosaur BarkBone is unique because it’s flavored with real bacon and dishwasher-safe, so you can regularly clean and sanitize it. It’s made of durable FDA-approved nylon that’s safe and non-toxic. It’s a long-lasting bone for aggressive chewers and helps clean dogs’ teeth and gums.

Many dogs don’t like the taste of this bone, and it has a strong smell. The material is too hard and may damage teeth. It’s also a heavy bone, so it can scratch floors.

---

7. CNMGBB No Stuffing Dog Toys

For dogs who like to play with plush dog toys, the CNMGBB No Stuffing Dog Toy is a durable option. It’s machine-washable, so you can easily keep it clean. As the name suggests, the toy is stuffing-free, so you won’t find plush innards all over your living room. It has a squeaky and inner crinkle paper to keep your dog interested.

Compared to others on the list, this toy isn’t as durable. It’s also not recommended for aggressive chewers. The seams are so easy to rip that dogs can tear it open and swallow the squeaker inside.

---

8. ZippyPaws Skinny Peltz – Fox, Raccoon, & Squirrel – No Stuffing Squeaky Dog Toy

The ZippyPaws Skinny Peltz include a toy fox, raccoon, and squirrel. The flat, plush toys are designed for smaller dogs, but large canines that are rough with their toys are likely to tear them apart quickly. Eat toy has three squeakers to entertain your dog, and like our previous pick, the ZippyPaws don’t have stuffing.

Customers with small or medium dogs were relatively happy with the ZippyPaws toys, but some mentioned that their pups tore them apart. Even if you have a small dog, they can still rip into the plush toys if they’re heavy chewers.  

---

9. West Paw Durable Dog Chew Toy

The West Paw Zogoflex Hurley Chew Toy is FDA-approved to be safe and non-toxic. It’s available in three sizes, so you can find the best one for your dog. It floats on water and is dishwasher-safe for easy cleaning.

This toy isn’t as durable as others on the list, and most dogs can easily chew it to pieces, which can either be swallowed or become a choking hazard. It isn’t the best toy for aggressive chewers. If the toy is destroyed, the manufacturer’s free replacement clause doesn’t include shipping costs.

---

10. Amazon Basics Dog Treat Dispensing Chew Toy

If you want to give your dog a treat while they chew, you can try the Amazon Basics Dog Treat Dispensing Chew Toy. The two-pack set allows you to stuff the toys with peanut butter, dry food, or dog treats.

Unfortunately, like several brands, the toys are designed for small to medium-sized canines. They’re made of durable rubber and don’t have the strong chemical smell of other toys, but they have a significant design flaw. 

The holes in the toys are too large to stuff small treats, and if you have a little dog, they might not be able to consume large chunks of kibble or treats.

Buyer’s Guide: Choosing the Best Indestructible Dog Toys

When you’re shopping for an indestructible dog toy, there are a few factors to keep in mind.

Type of Toy

Every dog has a unique personality, and the best type of toy for them will depend on what they like to play with. There are many brands of indestructible dog toys available, including balls, discs, tug toys, and chew toys.

You might consider tug toys, balls, or discs if you have a more playful dog. For quiet chewers, chew toys are best. Some toys are noisy or dispense treats, so if you don’t want to deal with that, you should probably choose a different type.

Size

In general, big dogs should have large, durable toys, and small dogs should have smaller toys. You always want to ensure the toy doesn’t pose a choking hazard to your dog, especially if you plan on leaving them alone with it.

Durability

For indestructible dog toys, durability is vital. They should be made of a material that can withstand aggressive chewing. You’ll find a few materials used in these toys. Natural rubber, double-knit rope, or tough nylon are all excellent choices, but rubber is considered the strongest.

Safety

If you’re looking for a toy that will entertain your dog while you’re away, safety is especially important. You must search for toys made from safe, non-toxic material. Some even have an FDA stamp of approval on their packages, which is a good indication of quality.

Guarantee

Some indestructible dog toys come with a manufacturer’s guarantee. This includes a promise to replace the toy at no cost if your dog can destroy it. For a pricier toy, this can give you the confidence to try it out with your dog.

In Conclusion

Our best overall choice is the GUCHO Freezable Dog Chew Toy because it can hold up to even the most aggressive chewer with its tough polymer-nylon material. It has special knobs and ridges to keep your dog’s teeth and gums healthy, and it’s easy to clean.

Our best value choice is the  Nylabone NCF315P Dura Chew Dog Toy because it comes in various flavors, chewing styles, and sizes. This allows you to find the best one to fit your dog’s preferences.

We hope our list of reviews and buying guide of the best indestructible dog toys have helped you find the best toy for your dog.

See also:

• Best Dog Bones for Aggressive Chewers – Reviews & Top Picks
• Best Bully Sticks for Dogs – Reviews & Top Picks

---

Featured Photo Credit: Hero Images Inc, Shutterstock