Hepper is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

Smalls vs Cat Person: Which Fresh Cat Food is Right for Your Cat? (2023)

Chelsie Fraser

By Chelsie Fraser

smalls vs cat person new feature

It can be difficult to choose the right food for your cat, and with more and more fresh food companies popping up, things are only getting more complex. To make it easier for you to narrow things down, we’ve compared two of the top fresh cat food brands on the market: Smalls and Cat Person.

Both of these brands are strong contenders for being the best fresh cat food options on the market thanks to their convenience and quality. Here’s everything you need to know about both of these brands.

Winning Recipes Compared

Rating Image Product Details
Smalls Fresh Smooth Bird Recipe Smalls Fresh Smooth Bird Recipe
  • Fresh food
  • High protein
  • Smooth texture for easier eating
  • Second place
    Cat Person Chicken & Turkey Recipe Dry Food Cat Person Chicken & Turkey Recipe Dry Food
  • High protein content
  • Excellent nutritional value
  • Chicken and turkey are the first ingredients
  • Brands at a Glance

    Smalls Cat Food

    Cat Person Cat Food
    Types of Food
    Types of Food:
    Wet (pate, ground), freeze-dried, kibble
    Types of Food:
    Wet (pate, shreds in broth), kibble
    Average Cost/oz
    Average Cost/oz:
    $0.78 (wet), $1.83 (freeze-dried), $1.75 (combination)
    Average Cost/oz:
    $0.34 (wet), $0.45 (kibble)
    Chicken, turkey, fish, and beef wet foods, chicken, turkey, and duck freeze-dried foods
    16 wet food recipes in pate and shreds in broth form, three kibble flavors
    Additional Info
    Additional Info:
    Offers discount on first order
    Additional Info:
    Custom meal plans and portion sizes available

    About Smalls

    smalls logo

    Smalls is a subscription-based cat food brand that is known for its unique food texture options. While the pate texture is pretty typical, the ground wet food is a great option for cats that prefer a chunkier texture to their normal wet food. The freeze-dried raw food features a smaller kibble size, making it suitable for cats of all sizes.

    Smalls offers a discount on the first order, usually 25%, which can save you a significant amount of money. You can customize the foods you receive and how frequently you receive them, but the Smalls website isn’t set up to allow you to easily or clearly view the recipes and prices before signing up for a subscription.

    Smalls uses human-grade ingredients, and you can feel good knowing that their ingredients are sourced from North America. On top of food, Smalls also offers a variety of non-food items, including cat litter and toys.

    • Multiple textures available
    • Multiple single-protein recipes to choose from
    • Discounted first order
    • Subscription can be fully customized
    • Unique texture options
    • Premium price
    • Difficult to view recipes without a subscription

    About Cat Person

    cat person fresh cat food logo

    Cat Person is unique in that they are not a cat food manufacturer. Their food is manufactured by an external company, and most of their food is manufactured in Thailand, although they recently opened a manufacturing plant in the United States that is powered by solar power. Their manufacturers are all committed to minimizing their carbon footprint and ethically sourcing their ingredients.

    Cat Person offers a variety of cat-related products aside from food, including toys and beds. In fact, they started off as a retailer of cat products and not cat food. Cat Person offers a wide variety of foods, coming in at 19 recipes, including wet and dry foods. They don’t claim to make human-grade foods, but their foods are produced in human food manufacturing plants, which indicates that there is some level of higher quality than your average cat food.

    Cat Person offers customizable subscription services for their food, so you can determine exactly how much you need and how frequently.

    • Committed to responsible manufacturing practices
    • Offers non-food products
    • 19 recipes to choose from
    • Foods produced in human food manufacturing plants
    • Subscription can be fully customized
    • Doesn’t produce their own foods
    • Premium price

    Other Top-Rated Cat Food Brands

    The Honest Kitchen
    Our rating: 4.5 / 5
    Open Farm
    Our rating: 4.5 / 5
    Our rating: 4.5 / 5

    Smalls’s Top-Rated Cat Food – Smooth Bird

    Smalls Fresh Smooth Bird Recipe

    The Smalls Smooth Bird Recipe is a great option for cats that prefer a pate texture wet food. It only contains chicken as its single protein source, making it suitable for cats with food sensitivities. This food is high in protein, as well as being very nutrient dense. It is a slightly drier texture than most wet foods, so you’re getting more nutritional bang for your buck, so to speak, than with most pate-style wet foods. This recipe is a great way to transition your cat over to Smalls foods if they are used to more traditional cat foods.

    Main Ingredients:

    • Chicken
    • Chicken liver
    • Green beans
    • Peas
    • Water (sufficient for processing)

    Guaranteed Analysis

    Crude Protein: 15.5%
    Crude Fat: 8.5%
    Crude Fiber: 1.5%
    Moisture: 72%

    Nutritional Breakdown

    Fat: 8.5%
    Protein: 15.5%
    Calories per ounce: 40 calories/oz.

    More Top Rated Recipes from Smalls

    Smalls Fresh Smooth Fish
    Our rating: 4.8 / 5
    Smalls Freeze-Dried Raw Water Bird
    Our rating: 4.8 / 5
    Smalls Fresh Ground Cow
    Our rating: 4.8 / 5
    Smalls Freeze-Dried Raw Other Bird
    Our rating: 4.8 / 5

    Find The Best Cat Food Brands in 2023

    Cat Person’s Top-Rated Cat Food – Chicken & Turkey Recipe Dry Food

    chicken and turkey dry cat person

    The Cat Person Chicken & Turkey Recipe Dry Food is a high-quality kibble that features multiple protein-dense ingredients. It’s a nutrient-dense food recipe that contains over 400 calories per cup, which means your cat can eat less without losing any nutrients. It’s low in carbohydrates and free of fillers, so you can feel good about giving it to your kitty.

    This food is designed to provide nutrition to cats in all life stages, although it may be too high in protein for elderly cats and those with kidney disease. It is primarily kibble, but it does contain real freeze-dried meat pieces throughout.

    Main Ingredients:

    • Chicken
    • Chicken meal
    • Turkey meal
    • Peas
    • Turkey

    Guaranteed Analysis

    Crude Protein: 40%
    Crude Fat: 20%
    Crude Fiber: 4%
    Moisture: 10%

    Nutritional Breakdown

    Fat: 20%
    Protein: 40%
    Calories per cup: 469 calories

    More Top Rated Recipes from Cat Person

    Cat Person Pate Chicken Recipe Wet Cat Food
    Our rating: 3.5 / 5
    Cat Person Mackerel & Bream Recipe Shreds in Broth
    Our rating: 3.5 / 5
    Cat Person Duck & Turkey Dry Food
    Our rating: 3.5 / 5
    Cat Person Beef Recipe Pate
    Our rating: 3.4 / 5

    Head-To-Head Comparison

    Best Value 💲

    • Cat Person

    Both of these brands are pricey, but Cat Person is easily the better value between these two brands. Their foods are less expensive per ounce than the foods offered by Smalls.

    Availability 🏪

    • Tie

    Smalls and Cat Person both offer customizable delivery schedules and a selection of foods to choose from. You can set your subscription to provide you with the right type and amount of food for your kitty.

    Natural Ingredients 🍏

    • Smalls

    While the ingredients from both brands are high in quality, Smalls responsible sources all of their ingredients from North America. Since they also manufacture their foods in North America, the ingredients have a shorter distance to travel, not to mention they are human-grade ingredients.

    Eco-Friendliness 🌱

    • Smalls

    Even though Cat Person uses manufacturers that are committed to responsible manufacturing, their foods are shipped across the world to be sold in the US, although they have recently started some US production. Smalls has a shorter shipping distance for their foods and ingredients alike. They also are committed to making their packaging and shipping materials as eco-friendly as possible.

    Animal Testing 🐁

    • Smalls

    Since both brands sell pet food, it goes without saying that their recipes are tested on animals. Their testing practices are not done on animals that are held specifically for the purpose of animal testing. Smalls manages to slightly edge Cat Person out of the competition, though. Since they make human-grade foods, Smalls employees actually taste-test the foods from time to time, ensuring flavor, safety, and quality are all there.

    Find The Best Cat Food Brands in 2023


    Smalls and Cat Person both offer great cat foods, but Smalls comes out on top. Smalls offers human-grade foods in multiple textures and varieties, including wet and dry options. Smalls does a great job of offering single protein foods, while Cat Person has a combination of single and multi-protein foods in 19 recipes and protein combinations. Both companies offer customizable subscription services that deliver your cat’s food right to your front door.

    If eco-friendliness is something that’s important to you, both companies offer options, but Smalls manages to come out on top when it comes to being eco-friendly. If having ingredients sourced in North America is important to you, then you’ll feel good about Smalls, which also manufactures their foods in the US. Cat Person sources their foods from reliable sources, but they primarily manufacture their foods in Thailand.

    If you’re looking for a more budget-friendly subscription cat food, then Cat Person is a great option for you. Smalls may be more expensive, but they make up for the higher price in the quality and reliability of their products.

    Related Articles

    Further Reading

    Vet Articles

    Latest Vet Answers

    The latest veterinarians' answers to questions from our database