Hepper is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

10 Best Natural & Organic Cat Foods – 2024 Reviews & Top Picks

Nicole Cosgrove Profile Picture

By Nicole Cosgrove

A Siamese cat eating dry food from a bowl Part of good cat ownership is providing them with a diet that meets all their nutritional needs. Part of being a good cat is to likely reject their owner’s healthy offerings and choose what tastes good instead.

Can healthy cat food still be appealing to your finicky friend? Cats are carnivores and require protein, fat, vitamins, and minerals to be healthy. These ingredients are important, but they’re often combined in many cat foods with potentially unhealthy fillers. To avoid feeding these fillers to your cat, natural and organic cat foods can offer a solution.

With so many different choices, though, it can be hard to know which one is best for your feline companion that will still please their palates. Our reviews cover the best all-natural cat foods on the market today.

Disclaimer: The foods reviewed here were chosen because they have certain characteristics that might help with some of the causes or consequences of this medical condition. However, they are not a medical treatment or a substitute for medical treatment. Keep in mind that each medical case is different and what works for some pets may not work for others. Your veterinarian is the right person to advise you on the best diet for your pet’s individual case.

hepper-cat-paw-divider

A Quick Comparison of Our Top Picks in 2024

Rating Image Product Details
Best Overall
Winner
Smalls Fresh Cat Food Subscription Smalls Fresh Cat Food Subscription
  • Uses human-grade meats
  • No preservatives or artificial colors
  • Contains natural vitamins and minerals
  • Budget Buy
    Second place
    Nature’s Logic Dry Cat Food Nature’s Logic Dry Cat Food
  • Good for all life stages
  • Probiotics for digestive health
  • Natural ingredients
  • Third place
    Open Farm Cat Food Open Farm Cat Food
  • Premium, sustainably sourced ingredients
  • High in all-natural protein
  • Made with non-GMO fruits & veggies
  • Purina Beyond Chicken & Sweet Potato Wet Cat Food Purina Beyond Chicken & Sweet Potato Wet Cat Food
  • No antibiotics or hormones
  • High in protein
  • Full of vitamins
  • Castor & Pollux Organix Dry Kitten Food Castor & Pollux Organix Dry Kitten Food
  • First ingredient is chicken
  • Omegas to support coat
  • Good price for organic food
  • The 10 Best Natural & Organic Cat Foods

    1. Smalls Human-Grade Fresh Cat Food – Best Overall

    Main ingredients: Chicken thigh, chicken breast, chicken liver
    Type: All-natural
    Suitable for: Adults

    Smalls Human-Grade Fresh Cat Food is a new brand on the market, having only been around since 2017. They only use human-grade meats in their small-batch products, meaning your cat is getting the best nutrition available. There are no artificial colors or preservatives added either, only what is shown on the ingredients list. The variety of flavors, such as chicken, turkey, and beef, means there will definitely be something for your picky kitty to enjoy and the home delivery option ensures that it’s convenient for you too!

    When our cats tried it, they couldn’t get enough. It’s healthy, tasty, and conveniently tailored to your cat. They have several fresh, gently cooked options with different recipes so you can select the protein that your cat loves most.

    To conclude, we think this is the best natural cat food out there.

    Pros
    • Human-grade meat used
    • All natural ingredients
    • 50% protein
    • No artificial colors or preservatives

    Cons
    • More expensive than store-bought food


    2. Nature’s Logic All Life Stages Dry Cat Food — Budget Buy

    Nature’s Logic All Life Stages Dry Cat Food

    Main ingredients: Chicken meal, chicken fat, pumpkin seed, chicken liver
    Type: All-natural
    Suitable for: Adults and kittens

    Our best value pick for all-natural cat food is Nature’s Logic All Life Stages Dry Cat Food. This food is made with over 60% animal protein as the first ingredient and contains no fillers like rice, corn, or soy. Nothing artificial is added to this product. It also includes fruits and vegetables, like apples, blueberries, and spinach, so you know your cat is getting essential vitamins and minerals. We like the probiotics included in the food to help support your feline’s digestive tract health.

    Some cats may find the chicken density to be too rich, while others have been reluctant to eat it after smelling it. All in all, we think this is the best natural cat food for the money available this year.

    Pros
    • Good for all life stages
    • Probiotics for digestive health

    Cons
    • May be too rich for some cats


    3. Open Farm Cat Food

    Open Farm Cat Foods and Broths

    *Use code HEPPER20 and save on your first auto-ship order.

    Main ingredients: Wild-caught Pacific salmon, non-GMO cranberries, garbanzo beans, pumpkin
    Type: Natural
    Suitable for: Adults & kittens

    Open Farm cat food is another great option that will provide your cat with plenty of all-natural protein and nutrients. The wild-caught salmon recipe features sustainably sourced Pacific salmon, non-GMO cranberries, garbanzo beans, pumpkin, coconut oil, and apples. It contains omega-3 fatty acids to keep your cat’s coat and skin healthy. Open Farm also offers a Turkey & Chicken recipe, Catch-of-the-Season Whitefish, Pasture-Raised Lamb, and a grain-free kitten option made with chicken, turkey, and whitefish.

    We love Open Farm’s focus on sustainable, natural sourcing of premium ingredients. If you’re looking for cat food that is great for your cat and for the world, this brand is a great option! The downside is that this premium food is a bit more expensive than some options. But if it fits into your budget, Open Farm is a great choice for your cat.

    Pros
    • Premium, sustainably sourced ingredients
    • High in protein
    • Made with non-GMO fruits & veggies
    • No antibiotics or hormones
    • All-natural

    Cons
    • Somewhat pricey


    4. Purina Beyond Wet Organic Cat Food

    Purina Beyond Wet Organic Cat Food

    Main ingredients: Organic chicken, organic sweet potatoes, organic chicken broth
    Type: Organic
    Suitable for: Adults

    Purina Beyond Organic Chicken & Sweet Potato Wet Cat Food is a high-protein product to support your cat’s muscle development. It contains no by-products, corn, or antibiotics. It’s free from GMOs. Offering prime, natural nutrition at a lower cost than other options, this is our pick for the best organic cat food for the money. This food is USDA-Certified Organic Seal approved, meaning it’s guaranteed to contain no pesticides, hormones, or preservatives, which is one of the main reasons we have chosen it as our premium choice.

    The recipe was changed recently to add more protein, and some cats who were eating this regularly suddenly stopped. The new recipe doesn’t seem to be a hit with cats who preferred the old one. Also, for canned cat food, there’s little gravy added. If your cats love gravy, they may find this food to be too dry, but adding a little water and stirring it up solves that problem.

    Pros
    • No antibiotics or hormones
    • High in protein
    • Full of vitamins

    Cons
    • Recent recipe change that cats might not like
    • Not much gravy


    5. Castor & Pollux Organix Dry Kitten Food

    Castor & Pollux Organix Grain-Free Organic Kitten Recipe Dry Cat Food

    Main ingredients: Organic chicken, organic chicken meal, organic sweet potato, organic tapioca
    Type: Organic
    Suitable for: Kittens

    A great choice if you are looking for kitten food is Castor & Pollux Organix Dry Kitten Food. Flaxseed and organic coconut oil help your kitten’s growth and development. Organic free-range chicken provides the protein that your kitten needs for healthy muscles. This food is made in the U.S.A. with natural organic ingredients. No synthetic fertilizers or hormones were used in the growing of these ingredients. Added omegas in this recipe help keep kitten coats shiny and full. There’s also added fiber to help keep hairballs at bay.

    Some kittens don’t find this food tasty and refuse to eat it. There have also been reports of kittens developing an allergy to it.

    Pros
    • First ingredient is chicken
    • Omegas to support coat
    • Good price for organic food

    Cons
    • Unpleasant smell

    6. Natural Balance L.I.D. Green Pea & Salmon Dry Cat Food

    Natural Balance L.I.D. Green Pea & Salmon Dry Cat Food

    Main ingredients: Green peas, salmon meal, canola oil, calcium carbonate, flaxseed
    Type: All-natural
    Suitable for: Adults

    The salmon and peas in Natural Balance L.I.D. Green Pea & Salmon Dry Cat Food have been reported to be gentle on the digestive system, especially if your cat has stomach sensitivities. The oils and omegas help support coat health, and there are no grains or artificial colors. This product is reported to be allergy-friendly, offering cats another option when they’re on a limited-ingredient diet. Loose stools and frequent vomiting are said to have cleared up after kitties have eaten this food.

    Some finicky cats have turned their noses up at it, though, preferring food without peas. Some people say that this food smells great, and others say that the smell is horrible, so it’s personal preference when it comes to the aroma of this food.

    Pros
    • Salmon is the main ingredient
    • Low carb

    Cons
    • Unpleasant smell
    • Picky cats don’t like the taste
    • Higher price than some other brands


    7. Nature’s Logic Rabbit Grain-Free Canned Cat Food

    Nature’s Logic Rabbit Grain-Free Canned Cat Food

    Main ingredients: Rabbit, pork liver, herring oil, eggshell meal
    Type: All-natural
    Suitable for: Adults

    Made with rabbit as the primary protein source, Nature’s Logic Rabbit Grain-Free Canned Cat Food contains over 90% protein. Not only does this food contain the essential vitamins and minerals that your cat needs, but it’s also low-carb and grain-free. It includes natural taurine from protein instead of being added synthetically. Some cats find the rabbit protein easier to digest than poultry, making this food gentle on the digestion system.

    The biggest downfall of this food is reports of it being so dry that water has to be added to it even though it’s canned food. There are also reports of the cans not being filled upon opening them.

    Pros
    • Protein-packed
    • Contains real fruit and vegetables

    Cons
    • Dry consistency
    • Can isn’t completely filled


    8. Evanger’s Grain-Free Medley with Rabbit Dry Cat Food

    Evanger’s Grain-Free Medley with Rabbit Dry Cat Food

    Main ingredients: Green peas, salmon meal, canola oil, calcium carbonate, flaxseed
    Type: All-natural
    Suitable for: Adults and kittens

    The medley of three types of meat in Evanger’s Grain-Free Meat Lover’s Medley with Rabbit Dry Cat Food is enticing to many cats. Beef and pork join rabbit in this food, making it a healthy choice for cats in any life stage. Skin and coat health are supported by the addition of omegas and flaxseed. The natural ingredients in this food have been said to relieve skin allergies, including hot spots. It’s a good choice for cats that are allergic to poultry, as it’s still full of protein.

    The biggest con is that cats have refused to eat it, either not liking the taste or the smell. Some have refused to even taste it.

    Pros
    • Made of three types of meat
    • Picky cats like it
    • Good for all life stages

    Cons
    • Some cats refuse to eat it


    9. Farmina Chicken & Ancestral Low-Grain Dry Cat Food

    Farmina Chicken & Ancestral Low-Grain Dry Cat Food

    Main ingredients: Boneless chicken, whole oats, whole spelt, whole eggs, herring
    Type: All-natural
    Suitable for: Adults and kittens

    Cats of all life stages can enjoy Farmina Chicken & Ancestral Low-Grain Dry Cat Food. This low-carb food is 94% protein from quality sources. Organic spelt, oats, fruits, and vegetables make up this low-grain recipe, along with vitamins and minerals. This food has been reported to help clear up bowel issues in cats. Others have said that it helped with getting more nutrition for their cats in a smaller amount than other foods.

    If cats are used to a higher-carb diet, it may take them a while to get used to this food. Kibble pieces are also bigger than other brands and may be harder for brachycephalic cats to eat.

    Pros
    • May help with bowel issues
    • Low carb
    • 94% protein

    Cons
    • Small bags
    • Expensive for the amount


    10. Stella & Chewy’s Turkey Freeze-Dried Raw Cat Food

    Stella & Chewy’s Turkey Freeze-Dried Raw Cat Food

    Main ingredients: Turkey with ground bone, turkey liver, turkey gizzard, pumpkin seed
    Type: All natural raw
    Suitable for: Adults

    Stella & Chewy’s Tummy Ticklin’ Turkey Freeze-Dried Raw Cat Food provides raw nutrition in a freeze-dried patty. If you choose to rehydrate the food, all you have to do is mix it with a little water. The benefits of a natural raw diet have been reported as improved immune systems, healthier skin, teeth, and gums, and allergy relief. The ingredients in this food closely mimic what a cat would eat in the wild. Some people use this as a treat throughout the day for their cats, breaking off small pieces of the patty at a time instead of using it as a meal.

    Some cats don’t like the texture even when the food is rehydrated. The bag is also awkwardly shaped, causing the patties to break apart. Even broken into pieces, though, the food is still able to be consumed.

    Pros
    • Freeze-dried for convenience
    • Can be used as a treat instead of a meal

    Cons
    • Dry
    • Some cats don’t like the texture
    • Patties crumble in the bag

    hepper cat paw divider

    Buyer’s Guide: Selecting the Best Natural & Organic Cat Food

    Cats have certain dietary requirements that if not met, can cause your cat to become ill. When choosing good-quality food for your cat, it is important to read all the ingredients carefully and know what you’re looking for in terms of necessity and nutrition.

    While providing our feline companions with high-quality food is paramount, selecting the right food and water bowl is equally important. The modern yet practical design of our Hepper NomNom Cat Bowl combines cat-catered features, like whisker-friendly shallow dishes and slight elevation, with a contemporary style aimed at protecting your floors from messy eating and drinking. The NomNom is entirely dishwasher safe and was thoughtfully created with your cat’s health and well-being in mind. 

    Hepper 360 Cat Feeder, Stainless Steel, Anti-Chew...
    • NO MESS - The 360° tray on this cat food and water bowl set has a raised design to catch and...
    • WHISKER FRIENDLY - Shallow and wide metal containers with flat bottoms ensure your kitty can enjoy...

    Nutritional Necessities for Your Cat

    Protein

    Cats are obligate carnivores, meaning they need meat in their diets or else they can die. A cat’s metabolism can’t appropriately digest a vegetarian diet. They require protein that is only found in the tissue of animals. Even if you’re a vegetarian, your cat can’t be. They need meat to survive. Plant protein is not enough to sustain them.

    Taurine

    Taurine is an amino acid found in animal protein. It is a crucial part of your cat’s diet for immune system health, vision, heart function, and digestion. In natural and organic foods, taurine occurs naturally in the ingredients. In other foods, taurine is synthetically added.

    Fat

    Cats eat moderate amounts of fat in the wild, and some fat is important for health. It is responsible for your cat’s energy level, providing more energy than carbs or protein. Omegas are important fatty acids that can heal inflammation and provide relief from arthritis. Other essential fatty acids for cats are linoleic acid and arachidonic acid.

    Carbohydrates

    Carbs provide energy for your cat’s body tissues and keep the intestines healthy. As with all carbohydrates, your cat doesn’t need that many; otherwise, it can result in weight gain.

    Vitamins and Minerals

    Your cat needs to get vitamins and minerals through diet because a synthetic supplement likely won’t be properly absorbed by your cat’s body. If you’re giving your cat a diet with the proper vitamins, then supplements are unnecessary. Most cats get their required nutrients through good, high-quality food.

    How Much Should a Cat Eat?

    The amount that your cat needs to eat will vary by dietary needs and weight. The recommended guidelines for feeding are on the backs of most food packages, but your vet can also suggest the proper amount. If you’d like your cat to gain weight, feed it according to the weight guidelines you’d like your cat to. If you’d like your cat to lose weight, feed the amount that a cat would get that’s already at the ideal weight. Kittens will need more food than adult cats. Their food is typically higher in fat and will provide more energy to kittens as they grow. Senior cats may need less food than younger adults because they don’t burn it off as quickly due to slower metabolisms. Your cat’s weight and age play a big part in the amount of food that they should eat every day.

    Is My Cat Starving?

    It’s a common joke that cats will act as if they’ve never eaten before for every meal. If your cat is constantly begging for more food, determine if it’s just a cat thing or if something else is going on. Lower-quality foods may not keep your cat full for that long. If you notice any weight loss, increased appetite, increased urination, or unusual vomiting, a trip to the vet is necessary to rule out any health problems. A common health issue in cats is hyperthyroidism, causing your cat to be hungry all the time. Fortunately, this condition can be treated.

    Beautiful feline cat eating on a metal bowl
    Image Credit: Krakenimages.com, Shutterstock

    Things to Consider When Choosing Cat Food

    Your Time

    How much time can you devote to your cat’s mealtimes? If you’re rushed, trying to get dinner ready for the people in the house, for example, you might not have much time to thaw or rehydrate raw food. Will you have time to fill the bowl with kibble or scoop out a can? Consider how much time your cat’s food takes to prepare and then plan accordingly.

    Your Cat’s Age

    If you have a young adult cat, don’t get food marketed toward a kitten or senior cat. Different cat foods are made with the nutritional needs in mind for each stage of a cat’s life.

    Your Cat’s Weight

    Cat food that is designed for weight control may allow your cat to eat the same amount of food while consuming fewer calories. Additionally, natural and organic foods are composed of fewer fillers, which means fewer empty calories and more nutrition per bite.

    hepper single cat paw divider

    Final Thoughts

    We hope that our reviews help you determine which natural or organic cat food will be best for your feline. Most cats will eat any food that you give them, so choosing the right one for your cat is important.

    Our choice for overall best natural cat food is Smalls Human-Grade Fresh Cat Food. It comes in multiple recipes to please every type of cat, and when it comes to quality ingredients and convenience, you can’t beat this brand. Nature’s Logic All Life Stages Dry Cat Food comes in for our best value choice, as it offers proper nutrition for all life stages and is filled with all-natural protein. Our third favorite all-natural cat food is Open Farm, which offers sustainably sourced foods packed with nutrients and premium proteins.

    See also:


    Featured Image Credit: catinrocket, Shutterstock

    Related Articles

    Further Reading

    Vet Articles

    Latest Vet Answers

    The latest veterinarians' answers to questions from our database

    Shopping cart0
    There are no products in the cart!