5 Best Budget-Friendly Dog Subscription Boxes — 2024 Reviews & Top Picks

Dog subscription boxes are convenient and fun-filled packages designed to bring joy and excitement to you and your pet. From tasty treats to engaging toys, these boxes provide a monthly surprise that keeps tails wagging. While some subscription boxes can be pricey, several budget-friendly options are available, ensuring that you can pamper your pup without breaking the bank. Keep reading for reviews of several of the most popular options so you can make an informed purchase.

A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites

The 5 Best Budget-Friendly Dog Subscription Boxes

1. BarkBox — Best Overall

The BarkBox is the best overall budget-friendly dog subscription box. It’s available in three sizes to accommodate small, medium, and large dogs, and each box includes two toys, two packs of treats, and a chew that will help keep your pet entertained. The treats use only high-quality, natural ingredients, and each box has an overall theme with activities that will help keep your pet mentally stimulated.

The only con about the BarkBox is that many customers complained that the toys aren’t durable enough for their pets.

---

2. Pet Treater — Best Value

The Pet Treater is the best budget-friendly dog subscription box for the money. It’s the cheapest option on this list and is perfect as a gift. Each box comes with a mix of three to four toys and treats that are hand selected. You can customize your subscription so it contains only treats or toys, and you can also upgrade to receive five to eight items each month for a few more dollars.

The downside to Pet Treater is that many customers complained that it could be hard to contact the company to cancel a subscription.

---

3. Super Chewer by BarkBox — Premium Choice

The Super Chewer by BarkBox is a premium-choice budget-friendly dog subscription box. It is specifically for tough chewers that go through the standard BarkBox toys too quickly. It has two chews that will help keep your dog busy, and the toys are more durable. Each box has a fun monthly theme that includes activities and two bags of treats that contain high-quality ingredients. You can purchase it in three sizes—small, medium, or large—and receive a good variety of toys.

The downside of the Super Chewer subscription is that many customers complained that their dogs still chew up the toys quickly.

---

4. Pup Box

The Pup Box dog subscription box is a great choice for the budget minded, and you can select from several different plans with a lower cost for a longer commitment. You also get to select a box that matches your puppy’s age, and the contents will grow with your pet. Puppy boxes contain plush toys, teething chews, and training essentials, while an adult will receive studier toys, along with tips and tricks to encourage activity. All treats use high-quality ingredients that are safe for your pet.

The only downside is that some customers complained that it was hard to cancel their subscriptions.

---

5. Pupjoy

Pupjoy is a great subscription box that will provide your pet with a surprise each month. Each box contains one toy, two bags of treats, and two bully sticks that will help keep them entertained. The treats use high-quality ingredients, and there are multiple plans to suit the size of your dog. You can even customize the box to receive more treats or toys. Finally, there are multiple plans with longer commitments and thus, lower prices.

The main con to Pupjoy is that it can be difficult to contact customer service if you have a question or need to adjust your plan.

Buyer’s Guide to the Cheapest Subscription Boxes

Price

Consider your budget, and determine how much you can spend on a monthly subscription. Look for subscription boxes that offer affordable pricing plans or discounts for longer subscription commitments to help bring down the cost.

Contents

Take a close look at what each subscription box offers to ensure that the products align with your dog’s preferences and needs. Choose a brand that offers a variety of treats, toys, and other items.

Customization

Some subscription boxes enable you to customize the contents based on your dog’s size, age, and preferences to ensure that you receive items suitable for your pet and help avoid any potential allergies or sensitivities. Some boxes will even let you customize them for aggressive chewers.

Quality

Check the products’ quality in the subscription box to ensure that the treats use high-quality ingredients and that the toys are durable and safe for your dog. Choose a subscription box that prioritizes the quality and safety of the items.

Reviews and Reputation

Read customer reviews, and check the reputation of the subscription box provider when possible. Look for feedback on the quality of products, customer service, and overall satisfaction to gain insights into the experiences of other dog owners that can help you make an informed decision.

Subscription Terms

Review the subscription terms, including cancellation policies, flexibility to skip a month, or how to adjust your subscription. Ensure that the terms align with your needs and preferences. Longer subscriptions can help you save money, but it’s harder to remember to cancel them at the end of the year.

A Good Cause (Giving Back)

Some subscription boxes partner with animal shelters or donate proceeds to animal-related charities. If supporting a cause is important to your family, look for subscription boxes that give back to the community.

Conclusion

When you’re choosing your next dog subscription box, we highly recommend our pick as the best overall among these reviews. The BarkBox is extremely popular because it’s available in several sizes and provides your pet with two toys, two treats, and one chew each month. Each box also centers around a unique and fun theme and provides activities that you can do with your dog. Our pick for the best value is the Pet Treater subscription, as you get three to four toys and treats each month, and you can even customize the plan to get all treats or all toys.

---

Featured Image Credit: Pixabay