7 Best Dog Food Can Lids – 2024 Reviews & Top Picks
Updated on
Knowing just how much pet food can cost, we all know how important it is to keep food as fresh as possible between meals. Many dogs may not eat an even number of cans of food per meal, so you have to find reliable lids to cover the wet food to keep it fresh until the next mealtime. We’ve reviewed our favorite dog food can lids to help you find the best lids for your needs, no matter the type of food you feed and the size of cans you use.
A Quick Comparison of Our Winners (2024)
| Rating | Image | Product | Details | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Best Overall
|
|
Frisco Silicone Pet Food Can Cover |
|
Check Price |
Best Value
|
|
Ethical Pet Can Covers |
|
Check Price |
Premium Choice
|
|
ORE Pet Can Cover |
|
Check Price |
|
Comtim Silicone Can Lids Universal Size |
|
Check Price | |
|
Comtim Silicone Reusable Stretch Can Lids |
|
Check Price |
The 7 Best Dog Food Can Lids
1. Frisco Silicone Pet Food Can Cover – Best Overall
| Number of lids: | Two |
| Can sizes: | 3 ounces, 5.5 ounces, 12.5–13.2 ounces |
| Color: | Gray, blue |
The Frisco Silicone Pet Food Can Covers are the overall best dog food can lids on the market. Thanks to their multi-size design, these lids can fit most pet food cans. Even though they’re designed with three can types in mind, they have some stretch to them, so they may fit a wider range of cans.
There are two lids per order in gray and blue colors, allowing you to color code your pet foods for multiple pets. These lids are dishwasher safe, and the small crevices can easily be cleaned with a toothbrush if needed. They feature a pull tab that makes them easy to remove from cans, and the tab has a hole in it, so these lids can be hung on a hook out of the way.
Some people report these lids having a strong smell that may take a few washes to remove.
- Fit most pet food cans
- Two lids per order
- Can be used to color code food
- Dishwasher safe
- Pull tab makes for easy removal
- Can be hung on a hook
- May need multiple washes to remove smell
2. Ethical Pet Can Covers – Best Value
| Number of lids: | Three |
| Can sizes: | 3.5-inch diameter |
| Color: | Pink, blue |
The Ethical Pet Can Covers are the best dog food can lids for the money we’ve found. These budget-friendly lids come with three lids in each order, two of which are pink and one is blue. They are not flexible, and some people do report the lids cracking over time, causing them to lose their secure closure abilities. However, they can fit just about any pet food can with a lid diameter of 3.5 inches. The pull tab has a hole in it, allowing you to hang the lids if desired and making them easy to get on and off of cans.
- Best value
- Three lids per order
- Fits all cans with a diameter of 3.5 inches
- Can be hung on a hook
- Pull tab makes for easy removal
- May crack over time
3. ORE Pet Can Cover – Premium Choice
| Number of lids: | Two |
| Can sizes: | 3 ounces, 5.5 ounces, 12.5–13.2 ounces |
| Color: | Green, black, gray, orange, cream, white, blue |
The ORE Pet Can Covers are the premium choice for dog food can lids. These lids are available in a wide variety of colors, and there are two lids per order. Each order includes two different color lids, allowing you to use these for color coding if desired. They can fit most pet food cans and have some flexibility, allowing you to adjust them to suit a variety of can sizes. The pull tab is smaller on these than on most other can lids, so they may not be very functional for removing the lids, but they can be used to hang them from a hook. They are dishwasher safe.
- Multiple colors available
- Two lids per order
- Can be used to color code food
- Fit most pet food cans
- Dishwasher safe
- Pull tab may not help with removal of lid
4. Comtim Silicone Can Lids Universal Size
| Number of lids: | One, two, three, six |
| Can sizes: | 3 ounces, 5.5 ounces, 12.5–13.2 ounces |
| Color: | Green, blue, orange, yellow, navy, pink |
The Comtim Silicone Can Lids Universal Size comes in four pack sizes, allowing you to select the number of lids you need. These stretchy lids can be fitted to almost any pet food can. They come in six different colors, allowing you to use them for efficient color coding. They’re flexible and durable, ensuring they last a long time.
Their pull tab is too small to be much help with removing the lids, but they can be hung from a hook. Some people report finding it difficult to get these lids’ rings to line up with the edges of a can lid, which can make it difficult to ensure proper sealing.
- Four pack sizes available
- Fit most pet food cans
- Six colors available
- Can be used to color code food
- Flexible and durable
- Pull tab may not help with removal
- May be difficult to seal properly
5. Comtim Silicone Reusable Stretch Can Lids
| Number of lids: | Four, six, nine |
| Can sizes: | 3 ounces, 5.5 ounces, 12.5–13.2 ounces |
| Color: | Blue, clear |
The Comtim Silicone Reusable Stretch Can Lids are available in three package sizes of four to nine lids. Each package includes some blue and some clear lids. These lids are made of stretchy silicone and can fit cans with a lid diameter as small as 2.55 inches but up to 3.5 inches. They have multiple built-in pull tabs that make removing these lids easy. They seal tightly, designed to be watertight, and are dishwasher safe.
They may stretch with use, so it’s important not to overstretch these lids. They also will only seal properly if the can is dry, so it’s important to dry any gravy from the edges of the can before use.
- Three pack sizes available
- Fit most pet food cans
- Multiple built-in pull tabs
- Watertight seal
- Dishwasher safe
- May stretch out with use
- Will only seal properly if the can is dry
6. Kwispel Silicone Stretch Can Lids
| Number of lids: | Three |
| Can sizes: | 5.5 ounces, 12.5–13.2 ounces |
| Color: | Yellow, blue, pink |
The Kwispel Silicone Stretch Can Lids include three stretch lids per order, and each lid is a different color, making these a good option for color coding. These lids are made to fit medium and large pet food cans, but they will not fit small cans properly.
They’re dishwasher safe, and they’re made of stretchable silicone, allowing you to get a secure fit on your pet food. They’re stretchy enough that some people even report finding them to be suitable for arthritic hands. Some people find these to get stretched out easily, so you’ll have to make sure not to overstretch these lids.
- Three lids per order
- Good option for color coding foods
- Made to fit medium and large cans
- Dishwasher safe
- May work for arthritic hands
- Won’t fit small cans properly
- May stretch out with use
7. OHMO Silicone Pet Food Lids
| Number of lids: | Two, three |
| Can sizes: | 2.5–3 ounces, 5.5 ounces, 12.5–13.2 ounces |
| Color: | White, blue |
The OHMO Silicone Pet Food Lids are available in package sizes with two small lids, two small lids, and a large lid, or two or three universal pet food can lids. These lids come in dark blue and white colors. They have cat ears on top of them, making for a cute look, but they lack proper pull tabs for use.
These silicone lids are dishwasher safe and built to be sturdy and flexible. Some people report not finding these lids to fit very tightly on certain types of cans, and it may be difficult to line up the edges of cans properly with the grooves in the lid.
- Four pack sizes available
- Different lid sizes available
- Cute cat ears on top
- Dishwasher safe
- No pull tabs
- May not fit tightly on some types of cans
- May be difficult to seal properly
Buyer’s Guide: Choosing the Best Dog Food Can Lid
Selecting the Right Dog Food Can Lids for Your Needs
The good news is that there is not a science to selecting the right lids, but you should know what you’re looking for. Not all lids will fit all can types and some offer a wider range of flexibility than others. Knowing the size of the cans you use will help guide you in selecting the right size lids. Some lids are made to be somewhat universal in their sizing, while others are pretty specific about which cans they’ll fit.
You might also want to consider the material you might prefer your lids to be. Hard plastic lids offer less flexibility in fit and sizing, and they tend to be more likely to crack or break than soft lids. Soft silicone lids offer more flexibility and durability but may be more expensive than hard plastic lids.
Final Thoughts
When it comes to things like lids for pet food, these reviews have shown that there are a variety of options available to you based on your specific needs and preferences. The best overall dog food lids are the Frisco Silicone Pet Food Can Covers, which are flexible, sturdy, and made to fit almost any pet food can. The budget-friendly pick is the Ethical Pet Can Covers, which are not only extremely affordable but also able to fit a variety of can sizes. The premium pick is the ORE Pet Can Covers, which are available in a variety of fun colors and are sturdy and functional.
Featured Image Credit: Amazon
