8 Ollie Dog Food Alternatives in 2024: Our Comparison
Updated on
There’s a subscription box for everything, and dog food is no exception. Imagine never having to leave your house to get pet food again or not ever worrying about whether your dog’s food is healthy. With a dog food subscription, you can receive high-quality vet-recommended dog food on your doorstep at predictable intervals.
Ollie is one of the most popular delivery services for dog food, but their recipes and prices don’t suit every dog or owner. That’s why we’ve collected and compared eight Ollie dog food alternatives so you can see all your options in one spot.
Keep reading to find our reviews of eight Ollie dog food alternatives you can subscribe to today.
A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites in 2024
| Rating | Image | Product | Details | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
PetPlate |
|
Check PetPlate Price |
|
|
The Farmer’s Dog |
|
Click to Save 50% + Get Free Shipping! |
|
|
Spot & Tango |
|
Check Spot & Tango Price |
The 8 Ollie Dog Food Alternatives
1. Nom Nom Beef Mash vs Ollie Fresh Beef Dog Food
Nom Nom is the first Ollie dog food alternative that we took a close look at. We compared Nom Nom’s Beef Mash recipe with Ollie’s Fresh Beef dog food, which features similar ingredients. Nom Nom’s Beef Mash contains ground beef, russet potatoes, eggs, carrots, and peas. Ollie’s Fresh Beef, on the other hand, features beef, sweet potatoes, peas, and less common ingredients like chia seeds, blueberries, and spinach.
Both formulas have very high-quality recipe formulations and simple-to-serve packaging. Both companies also use a unique blend of meats and vegetables that are pre-portioned to take the guesswork out of how much you need to feed your dog. Both companies work with veterinary nutritionists and advisors to ensure the meals they’re designing provide the right nutrients dogs need.
These fresh dog foods have a lot in common: great ingredients, individual packaging, and a premium price. Nom Nom’s Beef Mash contains fewer (and simpler) ingredients, and you may prefer it if your dog has allergies or food sensitivities. Otherwise, Nom Nom’s Beef Mash and Ollie’s Fresh Beef are great options for your dog.
2. PetPlate Barkin’ Beef Entree vs Ollie Fresh Beef
PetPlate is another Ollie alternative that may appeal to you if you have a smaller budget. We took a closer look at PetPlate’s Barkin’ Beef Entree and compared it to Ollie’s Fresh Beef recipe. PetPlate’s Barkin’ Beef is high in protein and contains ground beef, sweet potatoes, beef liver, carrots, apples, and peas. This is pretty similar to the ingredients in Ollie’s Fresh Beef.
PetPlate is unique as you can include organic treats and supplement cookies with every meal. Conversely, Ollie focuses on dog food (though you’ll receive a scoop and “puptainer” with your first shipment).
Both companies prompt you to fill out a short survey about your dog’s breed, activity level, weight, food sensitivities, and required dietary support before recommending the recipes they think are best. This great feature allows you to customize the food to keep your dog as healthy as possible.
The price of PetPlate depends on how big your dog is and how much they eat. Dogs on the full meal plan will get 100% of their nutrition from PetPlate. For example, if your pup needs 800 calories of food per day and you’re on the full meal plan, you’ll be looking at around $3.27 per day.
Dogs on the topper plan will only get 25% of their nutrition from PetPlate in the form of a food topper you mix with their current food. This plan starts at $1.18/day. On the other hand, Ollie starts at $4/day for small dogs and ranges up to $8 a day for larger dogs, making it significantly more expensive.
PetPlate’s Barkin’ Beef Entree is full of premium ingredients customized to your dog’s needs, and so is Ollie’s Fresh Beef. Both companies have a lot to offer, but PetPlate is more affordable and has more add-ons.
3. The Farmer’s Dog Chicken vs Ollie Fresh Chicken
The Farmer’s Dog is another fresh dog food subscription service that’s worth a look. We compared The Farmer’s Dog’s Chicken recipe to Ollie’s Fresh Chicken recipe. The Farmer’s Dog Chicken contains chicken, Brussels sprouts, chicken liver, bok choy, broccoli, and various vitamins.
Ollie’s Fresh Chicken contains chicken, rice, carrots, spinach, and chia seeds. These are both pretty simple recipes, but if you’re looking for grain-free fresh dog food, you’ll want to stick with The Farmer’s Dog. For both subscription services, before you can select meals for your pup, you’ll need to complete a questionnaire about your dog’s body size, activity level, eating style, and health issues.
The Farmer’s Dog automatically recommends recipes based on your questionnaire answers, as does Ollie, but you’re not stuck with the ones they choose. Every recipe is made fresh and then shipped to your door within a few days of being made.
The company doesn’t put any preservatives or fillers in any of its recipes, and everything from the ingredients and kitchens the recipes are made in meets the USDA standards for human consumption.
The bottom line is that The Farmer’s Dog Chicken is a high-quality dog food with convenient, sustainable packaging and a great grain-free recipe. The only downside is the price, and Ollie is more affordable.
4. Spot & Tango Turkey and Red Quinoa vs Ollie Fresh Turkey
Another fresh dog food service is Spot & Tango. We compared the Spot & Tango Turkey & Red Quinoa recipe with Ollie’s Fresh Turkey. Ollie’s Fresh Turkey also features kale, blueberries, carrots, and turkey liver, while Spot & Tango’s Turkey recipe includes red quinoa, spinach, eggs, apples, and more. Spot & Tango’s recipe includes more protein, at 13.69%, compared to Ollie’s 11%.
Spot & Tango, like most other dog food delivery services on our list, requires you to complete a questionnaire about your dog’s health before providing recommendations. Spot & Tango’s Fresh Plan is made with fresh and whole ingredients that are cooked in small batches.
The texture is soft, and the meals come in pre-portioned packs for easy serving. Since they’re made with fresh ingredients, you must store them in the fridge or freezer. The price of your dog’s meal will depend on their size and feeding requirements.
Spot & Tango’s Fresh plans start at $2 per day, whereas Ollie’s fresh food starts at $4 per day. For both subscription services, it is easy to adjust the portions, change recipes, and skip or delay deliveries with the online ordering systems.
5. JustFoodForDogs Chicken & White Rice vs Ollie Fresh Chicken
If your dog has medical needs, JustFoodForDogs might be the Ollie alternative dog food delivery service for you. The company works closely with veterinary nutritionists to bring you well-balanced recipes and prescription meals.
The subscription process is more involved if your dog requires a prescription diet. You must submit your pup’s medical records so the JustFoodForDogs nutritional team can build a custom diet.
For this comparison, we compared the JustFoodForDogs Chicken & White Rice option to Ollie’s Fresh Chicken recipe. The JustFoodForDogs recipe includes chicken thighs, liver, gizzards, white rice, spinach, carrots, and apples. The Ollie Chicken recipe is similar, with chicken, rice, carrots, spinach, and chia seeds.
Ollie’s version contains 10% protein, while JustFoodForDogs only contains 8% protein. As with Ollie, when you complete the questionnaire, they will automatically recommend a few recipes based on your dog’s size, health status, and activity level. You can adjust the shipping frequency for both companies and skip deliveries as needed.
6. Open Farm Pet Grass-Fed Beef vs Ollie Fresh Beef
Open Farm Pet’s Grass-Fed Beef Gently Cooked recipe has several things in common with Ollie’s Fresh Beef dog food, which is why we picked it for this comparison. Open Farm Pet’s version contains beef, beef liver, carrots, kale, zucchini, and more. You won’t find wheat, potatoes, corn, or peas in their recipes.
On the other hand, Ollie’s Fresh Beef contains peas and potatoes, along with beef, sweet potatoes, beef kidney, and liver. If you’re concerned about feeding your dog peas or potatoes, the choice is simple: Open Farm Pet. However, many dogs can safely eat those ingredients. Open Farm Pet’s Grass Fed Beef contains 9% protein, while Ollie’s Fresh Beef contains 12%.
Open Farm Pet’s questionnaire is unique as it asks what your goals are for your dog. Do you want to focus on skin and coat health? Maybe your dog needs digestive support or could benefit from having more energy. If your pup is getting older, you might consider joint and mobility support as a health goal.
Their survey also takes into account which proteins your dog prefers. Open Farm Foods is very transparent about its ingredients. Using the lot code printed on the packaging, you can even trace the source of each ingredient, most of which come from the United States and Canada. Ollie doesn’t offer this level of specificity.
7. A Pup Above Texas Beef Stew vs Ollie Fresh Beef
A Pup Above differs slightly from other dog food delivery services like Ollie as you do not need to complete a survey about your dog’s needs, activity level, or health status before subscribing. To start receiving your auto-shipped dog food, you only need to select the flavor of food you’d like to receive, the size of the bag (3 pounds or 7 pounds), and the shipping frequency (anywhere between every 1 and every 8 weeks).
We compared A Pup Above’s Texas Beef Stew with Ollie’s Fresh Beef. A Pup Above’s recipe clocks in at 16.3% protein and contains beef, beef liver, tomatoes, green peas, carrots, and russet potatoes. It’s made with non-GMO veggies, a gravy rich in collagen and amino acids, and superfoods like turmeric, thyme, and parsley for digestive support.
Each ingredient in every recipe serves a specific purpose, which you can determine when you visit their website. They even claim their recipes have 77% more protein than other popular dog food delivery services. Ollie’s Fresh Beef has 12% protein, which is about 30% less than A Pup Above.
8. Lucky Dog Cuisine Turkey N’ Rice vs Ollie Fresh Turkey
Lucky Dog Cuisine produces all-natural meals devoid of any allergy-causing additives. They have seven meals to choose from, each of which has been cooked in the week before shipping. This company prides itself on being family-owned and self-funded, and the owners have very close ties to their suppliers.
They never use dead, diseased, dying, or disabled animal products in their recipes. Lucky Dog Cuisine has a no-obligation subscription special that includes 14 one-pound packages of their all-natural meals for just $79.00. Future shipments will be sent out every 28 days and cost $159 with free shipping.
We compared the Lucky Dog Cuisine Turkey N’ Rice recipe to Ollie’s Fresh Turkey recipe. Lucky Dog’s turkey recipe contains 8.8% protein and includes turkey, brown rice, yogurt, carrots, and green beans. Ollie’s turkey recipe has more protein, at 11%, and uses lentils, kale, carrots, and turkey liver.
Buyer’s Guide for Comparing Ollie Dog Food Alternatives
Choosing a dog food delivery service is no simple feat. There are several factors you need to consider before clicking the Subscribe button.
Price Per Portion
Unless money is no object to you, the price of the service could be the most significant factor. Of course, it’s cheaper to feed your dog food from Wal-Mart, but the money you’re saving by choosing poor-quality food will need to be spent on your dog’s vet bills.
The price you’ll pay per portion is something you need to know before you subscribe. You don’t want to go through all the trouble of switching your dog to a new diet only to find that you can’t keep paying the bill every month.
You can keep costs down by choosing not to feed your dog delivery service food exclusively. You can cut costs in half but still reap the benefits of a fresh diet by feeding 50% delivery food and 50% food from another health-conscious brand.
Since most dog food delivery services base their price per portion on the size, breed, and dietary requirements of each dog, we weren’t able to provide an exact price point for every service. You can take the no-obligation questionnaires on every website to get a more accurate idea of what you’ll pay per portion.
Quality
Every delivery service on our list provides top-notch and high-quality food. Many of them work alongside veterinarians and pet nutritionists so they can formulate the best and most nutritious meals possible.
Most of the delivery services above are very transparent about how their recipes are produced. Many have detailed web pages that explain where their ingredients come from and how they prepare their foods. If the quality of your dog’s food is important, we recommend educating yourself on potential delivery services’ food preparation and sourcing processes.
How to Get the Most from Your Dog Food Delivery Service
Your job isn’t done once you decide which delivery service works best for your dog’s needs. There are some steps you need to take before you let your dog dive into the new food.
Consult With Your Vet
While the pre-subscription questionnaires address your dog’s needs, their systems aren’t perfect. You should still talk with your vet before changing their diet. Your vet can use your pup’s health history to determine if the delivery service you’ve settled on is the best option for your dog.
Introduce New Foods Slowly
You should never abruptly stop feeding your dog the food they’ve been eating regularly. New foods and diets need to be introduced slowly to prevent gastrointestinal upset. Dogs with sensitive stomachs may need an even longer transitional period.
The longer you take to introduce the new food, the easier it’ll be for you to determine if your dog is having any unexpected reactions to the new diet. If you stop feeding the food they’ve been eating for three years and immediately serve the delivery service food, you won’t know if the GI symptoms they’re displaying result from the ingredients of the new food or the sudden transition.
Store the Food Correctly
All of the delivery services we reviewed make fresh dog food. They need to be stored in the fridge or freezer to keep them safe for consumption. Consult with your delivery service to see how their meals need to be stored and how soon after receiving your delivery they need to be eaten. Leftovers should be stored in an airtight plastic or glass container.
Final Thoughts
When shopping for a fresh dog food delivery service, it can be hard to determine which is best. If you’re comparing Ollie to other companies, we have a few tips! PetPlate is an affordable way to switch your dog to a fresh diet, and its recipes with meat, veggies, and fruits make its quality unparalleled. The Farmer’s Dog and Spot & Tango are also good options.
We hope reading our comparisons of eight top Ollie dog food alternatives has given you an idea of which subscription service works best for your pup.
See Also:
- Ollie Fresh Dog Food Review: Pros, Cons & Verdict
- A Pup Above Fresh Dog Food Review: Expert’s Opinion
Featured Image Credit: chaoss, Shutterstock
