Hepper is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

6 Chewy Online Pet Store Alternatives in 2024: Comparisons & Top Picks

Hallie Roddy

By Hallie Roddy

cat sitting in a cardboard box with dry food and snack

Chewy is an online pet store that has revolutionized the way that we can shop for pet food and supplies. Instead of having to trek all the way to the nearest pet shop and search through aisles of supplies, Chewy has provided a way to find everything we need all in one place and have it delivered to our doors within days. Between supplements, medications, food, toys, collars, and first aid equipment, it’s hard to find sites that offer as much as Chewy does.

That said, there are a few comparable online pet stores with excellent reviews that you can use instead. Let’s look at six of them below.

hepper single cat paw divider

A Quick Look at Our Favorites of 2024

Rating Image Product Details
Amazon Amazon
  • Lots of reviews
  • Easy to find pet products
  • Free and next-day shipping with Prime
  • Second place
    Petco Petco
  • Price matching
  • Online pharmacy
  • Free 1–2 day shipping when you spend over $35
  • Third place
    PetSmart PetSmart
  • Offers curbside pickup
  • Free shipping over $49
  • Save when you buy online
  • The 6 Chewy Alternatives Compared

    1. Amazon vs Chewy

    chewy vs amazon

    Does it really come as any surprise that Amazon is the best alternative to Chewy online? While Amazon sells nearly anything you can think of, it also has an extensive product range for pet products, including food, cages, toys, treats, bedding, and more. It isn’t only limited to cats and dogs, but to all animals that we keep as pets. If you have an Amazon Prime account, you can get free shipping and next-day shipping, which is even faster than Chewy.

    The products are very easy to find and offer plenty of user reviews as well. The most significant disadvantage of shopping through Amazon is that the products can be dispatched from other suppliers. On top of that, there are no prescription medications available for purchase yet.

    2. Petco vs Chewy

    Petco vs Chewy

    What we love most about Petco is that it’s a well-known, trusted retailer with an excellent selection of products. Because it’s so large, you can often find great prices and deals. They aren’t exclusive to dogs and cats, either—Petco offers products for all sorts of pets.

    Petco offers free, 1–2 day shipping when you spend over $35, plus an online pharmacy, price-match guarantees, and an option to pick the products up in-store if you prefer. However, it doesn’t have the best reviews regarding customer service.

    3. PetSmart vs Chewy

    Petsmart vs Chewy

    Another well-known large retailer for selling pet products is PetSmart. PetSmart has a huge range of choices when it comes to the brands and products offered. Better yet, the prices offered online are sometimes even lower than what you see in its physical stores. Free shipping is available when you spend over $49, which is higher than other stores, however, PetSmart often offers discount codes if you choose to collect the products using curbside pickup.

    The biggest complaint from customers is that delivery can be slow, so you might consider driving to the store or using curbside pickup instead.

    4. Allivet vs Chewy

    Allivet vs Chewy

    Allivet is a site similar to Chewy in that it offers thousands of pet products while offering 5% off when you take advantage of its auto-ship program. Allivet also includes free shipping when you spend over $49 on your order. There are products available for all animals, including dogs, cats, birds, fish, livestock, and horses, including medication, food, and toys.

    The company does not usually have any large sales, so you might find that products are a little more expensive through this site. For this reason, the win goes to Chewy for their unbeatable prices and range of products.

    5. BudgetPetCare vs Chewy

    BudgetPetCare vs Chewy

    This pet store is the place to go if you want to save as much money as you can. It offers free shipping on all orders as long as you live within the United States, and like Chewy, there are tons of food options, treats, and toys for a wide variety of pets. The special deals are limited to a certain number of products, but the company still offers a few bonus programs for the more you shop. What many customers love is the have an online chat service to answer any questions you may have.

    6. Only Natural Pet vs Chewy

    Only Natural Pet vs Chewy

    Only Natural Pets is a little different than many of the other online pet stores on this list. It focuses on selling holistic, natural, and eco-friendly products. While this is great for your pet’s health, it also means you have limited products to choose from. However, the site still has a decent variety of foods, toys, gear, vitamins, grooming, and cleaning supplies to choose from. It also offers helpful articles and videos in its Holistic Healthcare Library.

    hepper cat paw divider

    Buyers Guide: Choosing an Online Pet Store

    While you might not be looking for a specific product, choosing where you buy your pet’s supplies is an important decision. Most pet owners are looking to buy from a website that offers a few different things. Let’s look at a few factors to consider.

    Range of Products

    There is no point in shopping with an online pet store if it doesn’t carry a fairly large range of products for you to look through. Sometimes you know exactly what you want and can find it with ease. Other times, you aren’t quite sure what you’re looking for and need a lot of options to compare.

    When an online store has hundreds of products to choose from, it makes it easy to narrow down your choices with filters. The more products a website has to offer, the more likely you are to find exactly what you’re looking for.


    Have you ever been online shopping and assumed that you’ve stuck to your budget, only to be shocked by the cost of shipping when you go to checkout? One thing that many online shoppers are looking for is free shipping. Most online stores will not offer free shipping unless you have an account with them or spend a certain amount of money. This isn’t ideal for someone who is only spending a few dollars, but it can come in handy when you’ve got a lot of products to buy at one time.

    Online Shopping
    Image Credit: Karolina Grabowska


    One way that retailers bring you into their stores is with sales. The same applies to online pet stores. When an online pet store offers lots of sales, it brings more traffic to its website, and it can help you save a lot of money throughout the year.

    hepper cat paw divider

    Final Thoughts

    We hope these reviews have shown you that you don’t have to rely on Chewy for all of your pet supply needs. While Chewy is wonderful, it is sometimes out of stock on the products you need right now. That’s when other websites come into play. The top alternative for this is Amazon, in our opinion. However, places like Petco and PetSmart do a decent job as well.

    See Also:

    Featured Image Credit: AssiaPix, Shutterstock

    Related Articles

    Further Reading

    Vet Articles

    Latest Vet Answers

    The latest veterinarians' answers to questions from our database