If you are a cat owner, you know it can be difficult to get food for your pet, especially during COVID, as many grocery stores have empty shelves. Cat food subscription services can be a great way to ensure that you always have food in the home, but it can be challenging to find one suitable for you and your pets with so many services available. We’ve chosen several to review for you so you can see the differences between them. We’ll give you the pros and cons we experienced with each one and tell you how it worked for our cats. We’ve also included a short buyer’s guide to help you know what to look for if you continue to shop around.
A Quick Comparison of Our Winners in 2023
|Best Overall||Smalls Fresh Cat Food||
||Click to Save 40%|
|Best Value||Cat Person Cat Food||
|Darwin's Natural Pet Products Fresh Cat Food||
||Click Here For Free Shipping!|
|Best for Kittens||Raised Right Fresh Cat Food||
|Savage Cat Food||
The 6 Best Fresh Cat Food Subscription Services
1. Smalls Fresh Cat Food Subscription – Best Overall
|Cost:||$90-$100 per month|
|Type:||Soft food and freeze-dried raw|
Smalls is our overall best cat food subscription service. You can select from multiple proteins like beef, turkey, and chicken, and each recipe uses high-quality human-grade ingredients with no chemical preservatives or artificial colors. It has a pleasant smell, and they even provide you with meal plans that can lead to weight loss, helping to keep your cat healthy.
The downside to Smalls is that it’s quite expensive, and many plans can cost more than $100 per month, so it might not be a great choice if you have several cats.
All in all, we think this is the overall best fresh cat food delivery service out there.
2. Cat Person Cat Food Subscription – Best Value
|Cost:||$20-$30 per month|
|Type:||Soft and Hard|
Cat Person is our pick as the best cat food subscription service for the money. You can choose from a large selection of wet and dry food, so you are sure to get something your cat enjoys, and they even have treats available. There are 19 recipes, each featuring a high-quality protein like turkey, beef, or fish, and each recipe is grain-free with no corn or soy ingredients.
We like the low cost of Cat Person, but it’s challenging to know what to order at first. They have a few basic plans, but it’s more difficult if you want something else, and building a plan could get much more expensive.
3. Darwin’s Natural Pet Products Fresh Cat Food
|Cost:||$20-$40 per month|
Darwin’s Natural Pet Products is a popular subscription service due to it serving cats and dogs with high-quality food. Its ingredients are 100% minimally processed real meat that will closely resemble your cat’s natural diet. Protein from chicken, turkey, or lamb ensures your cat has plenty of energy and strong muscle. A handy food calculator on their website makes it easy to choose your subscription.
The downside to Darwin’s Natural Pet Products is that it requires freezer space, and some users report packages were thawed during shipping.
4. Raised Right Fresh Cat Food Subscription Service – Best for Kittens
|Cost:||$20-$30 per month|
Raised Right is our pick as the best cat food subscription service for kittens. It uses all human-grade ingredients to provide your pet with a complete and well-balanced meal. High-quality protein from chicken or turkey will help your kitten develop strong muscle without upsetting its stomach. There are no corn or soy ingredients, and it’s portioned in one-pound bags to preserve freshness. One feature we liked a lot was the ability to order a sample pack at a lower cost to try it out before committing to the subscription.
The downside to Raised Right is that there isn’t a lot of variety, and you are pretty much stuck with either chicken or turkey.
5. Savage Cat Food
|Cost:||$40-$60 per month|
Savage Cat Food is another subscription that deals with mostly raw food. Raw food is great for cats because it’s what they naturally eat, and there are no fillers or chemical preservatives that might upset your pet’s sensitive digestion. There are multiple varieties available, including chicken, duck, and rabbit, so your cat should find something it enjoys, and we like that it comes in individual portions, so there is no guessing or overfeeding.
What we don’t like about Savage Cat Food was similar to other frozen foods is that they require freezer space, so it can be hard to find room for them, especially when the monthly supply arrives.
6. Bobcat Raw Cat Food
|Cost:||$100-$150 per month|
As you may have guessed from the name, Bobcat Raw Food delivers primarily raw food that’s well suited to your cat’s natural diet. He uses all high-quality ingredients like chicken, pork, elk, rabbit, and venison to provide your pet with plenty of high-quality, easy-to-digest protein. Pre portion meals prevent you from overfeeding and make sure you have enough until your next scheduled delivery, and the flat packages make it easier to store.
Even though the flat packages make it easier to store, Bobcat Raw Food still requires plenty of freezer space unless you will get a delivery every week or two. Some varieties also have a slightly bad odor that our cats don’t like, and it was challenging to transition them.
Buyer’s Guide: How to Choose the Best Fresh Cat Food Subscription Service
Most people will look at the cost per month of each brand when choosing a subscription-based food. We tried to list a ballpark cost for each brand in our reviews, but you should use this only to see what fits in your budget and choose your food based on other factors.
The proper ingredients are essential to a healthy cat, and it’s the most important thing to look at when choosing a cat food subscription service. We recommend a service that builds its recipes around real meat like chicken, turkey, or fish. Cats are carnivores, so they don’t need a lot of grain, and we recommend avoiding any brands that contain corn or soy products as these are empty fillers that can leave your cat feeling hungry. We chose only brands that use high-quality ingredients in our reviews, but you will need to stay vigilant if you continue to shop.
Packaging and Storage
Many people don’t consider the packaging until it’s too late, but you will need to store the food when it arrives, and many brands require refrigeration and even freezing. You will order a month’s supply or more, so even a small kitten will need plenty of freezer space. If you can’t afford or don’t have space for a second unit, you may need to choose an option that doesn’t require freezing.
Cooked vs Raw Food
Manufacturers cook the vast majority of cat food, but raw food is becoming more and more popular. Raw cat food is easier for cats to digest than cooked food or dry kibble, and it more closely resembles their natural diet. However, bacteria grow quickly and easily in raw food, so we don’t recommend preparing raw meals yourself. When you purchase raw food from a subscription service, nutritional experts prepare the recipe to provide the highest quality nutrition, and the company packages the food in a sterile environment. There should be no health risks as long as you follow the instructions carefully on the package and remove the food when your cats finish eating, and it’s especially helpful for cats with chronic GI troubles.
When choosing your next cat food subscription service, we highly recommend our choice pick for the best overall. Smalls is a popular and well-respected brand to provide your cat with high-quality ingredients. Another smart choice is our pick for the best value. Cat Person is relatively inexpensive and provides you with a large selection.
We hope you have enjoyed reading over these reviews and found a service you’d like to try. If we helped make your cat’s mealtime more convenient, please share this guide to the best cat food subscription service and Facebook and Twitter.
Featured Image Credit: PxFuel