Hepper is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

20 Irish Setter Pros & Cons You Should Know

Nicole Cosgrove Profile Picture

By Nicole Cosgrove

irish setter lying on the ground

With its vibrant auburn coat and charming disposition, the Irish Setter has captured the hearts of dog lovers for generations. Renowned for its elegant appearance and affable nature, this breed embodies the perfect blend of beauty and companionship.

From their energy and loyalty to the challenges of grooming and exercise, understanding the full spectrum of characteristics that define the Irish Setter is crucial for those considering these four-legged beauties as part of their family.

In this article we explore the 20 notable advantages and disadvantages of welcoming these spirited canines into your home. Whether you are a potential owner seeking insights or a curious enthusiast, this list will provide valuable insights into the delightful yet demanding world of Irish Setters!


The 10 Irish Setter Pros

1. Beautiful Appearance

The Irish Setter’s most iconic feature is its stunning, deep auburn coat, which radiates elegance and draws admiration wherever they go. Their regal bearing and graceful physique make them a captivating breed, often likened to works of art in motion.

2. Friendly and Good Natured

Irish Setters are famous for their warm and welcoming disposition. Their friendliness knows no bounds, and their good-natured attitude makes them ideal companions for people and other pets alike, fostering an atmosphere of positivity and harmonious living.

irish setter dog jumping on its owner
Image Credit: AlexandrinaZ, Shutterstock

3. Playful and Energetic

These dogs are a source of enthusiasm and energy, approaching life with infectious joy that’s bound to brighten your days. Their vivacious spirit and love for play make them the perfect partner for those who enjoy active lifestyles and outdoor adventures.

4. Affectionate

Irish Setters are masters of expressing love and affection. Their devotion to their owners is unwavering, and they thrive on being close. Showering their families with endless cuddles and adoration, Irish Setters forge heartwarming bonds that last a lifetime.

5. Good with Children

Irish Setters have a natural inclination for children. Their playful disposition and their gentle nature ensure that they make excellent playmates for kids. These dogs can easily create special and cherished friendships within the family.

Portrait of cute blonde girl playing with Irish Setter dog on floor in cozy home interior
Image Credit: SeventyFour, Shutterstock

6. Intelligent and Highly Trainable

With intelligence and a desire to please, Irish Setters are easily trainable. They excel in various training activities and respond well to positive reinforcement, turning the training process into a rewarding and enjoyable experience for both owner and dog.

7. Sociable

Inherently sociable, Irish Setters thrive on being part of the family’s daily life. Their presence enhances the warmth and camaraderie within the household, and they eagerly join in on family activities, making every moment feel special.

8. Alertness

Irish Setters possess a keen sense of alertness and are often vigilant watchdogs, quick to spot any unusual activity or potential threats, providing an additional layer of security to your home and loved ones.

Irish Setter
Image Credit: Kseniia Kolesnikova, Shutterstock

9. Long Life Span

Irish Setters enjoy a relatively long lifespan, often living to be 12 to 14 years old. This extended companionship allows for profound and enduring relationships, creating years of cherished memories and mutual devotion.

10. Extremely Loyal

Loyalty is at the core of the Irish Setter’s nature. They form unbreakable and devoted bonds with their owners, demonstrating unwavering loyalty, always ready to stand by your side and provide a source of unwavering comfort and companionship.

hepper-dog-paw-divider 4

The 10 Irish Setter Cons

1. High Energy Level

The Irish Setter’s unbridled enthusiasm can be a double-edged sword, as their boundless energy often requires owners to keep up with their spirited antics. Failing to provide an outlet for their vitality may lead to restlessness and mischief, challenging individuals unprepared for the breed’s exuberance.

red and white irish setter running on the grass outdoors
Image Credit: Glenkar, Shutterstock

2. High Exercise Requirement

Irish Setters demand substantial exercise, making them better suited for active households. Failing to meet their exercise needs can lead to boredom and restlessness, potentially resulting in destructive behaviors as they seek stimulation in the absence of physical activity.

3. Heavy Shedders

While their striking, flowing coat is their crowning glory, it comes with the downside of substantial shedding. Owners must be prepared for frequent grooming and cleaning to manage the shedding, which may be a significant drawback for those who prefer low-maintenance grooming routines.

4. High Maintenance Grooming

The stunning coat that characterizes Irish Setters necessitates regular grooming and maintenance to prevent matting and tangles. This can be a time-consuming and potentially costly endeavor for owners who value a well-groomed pet.

irish setter dog outdoors
Image Credit: No-longer-here, Pixabay

5. Susceptible to Health Issues

Irish Setters are prone to certain health concerns, such as hip dysplasia and bloat, which may result in considerable veterinary expenses and emotional stress for their owners. Regular health check-ups and preventive measures are vital for their well-being.

6. Stubborn and Independent Streaks

While intelligent, Irish Setters can exhibit stubborn and independent traits, potentially making training a challenge, particularly for novice dog owners. Patience and consistent training methods are essential when dealing with their occasional obstinacy.

7. Destructive Behavior

Without proper exercise and mental stimulation, Irish Setters can engage in destructive behaviors like chewing on furniture or household items, which can be a significant frustration for owners unprepared to provide adequate mental and physical stimulation.

irish setter lying on the couch
Image Credit: WiP-Studio, Shutterstock

8. Prey Drive

Irish Setters have a strong prey drive, which can lead to chasing small animals if not properly trained and supervised. This instinctual behavior may pose a risk to wildlife or other pets in the neighborhood.

9. Not Ideal for Small Living Spaces

Due to their size and high exercise requirements, Irish Setters are better suited to homes with large, secure yards. They may not thrive in small living spaces, making apartment living a less-than-ideal choice.

10. Care is Time-Consuming

From grooming and exercise to training and healthcare, the care of Irish Setters can be time-consuming. Owners should be prepared to invest a significant amount of time and effort in meeting their demanding needs for the duration of their long and fulfilling lives.

Red Irish Setter puppy at a dog show
Image Credit: Glikiri, Shutterstock

hepper-dog-paw-divider 3


The Irish Setter presents a compelling choice for dog enthusiasts, but one that requires careful consideration.

Its numerous pros, such as its affectionate nature, trainability, and longevity, make it a wonderful family companion. However, the cons, including their high energy levels, grooming demands, and potential health issues, underscore the importance of being well-prepared for the responsibilities that come with this breed.

Irish Setters are not just pets; they are enthusiastic, loyal, and energetic family members that require dedicated care and attention. As with any decision involving a furry friend, prospective owners should weigh these advantages and disadvantages carefully, ensuring that the match is a harmonious one. If it is, the bond formed with an Irish Setter can be both enduring and heartwarming.

Featured Image Credit: TMArt, Shutterstock

Related Articles

Further Reading

Vet Articles

Latest Vet Answers

The latest veterinarians' answers to questions from our database